Ontario lets you leave your property as you choose, so a will built on Islamic inheritance rules is enforceable here. Three things can override one anyway: a dependant's claim under the Succession Law Reform Act, a married spouse's election under the Family Law Act, and a document that was not executed properly.
Our charges include applicable taxes. Disbursements are extra and billed at cost — itemized upfront, in writing, never hidden.
From $563.87 taxes included
Ontario does not dictate who inherits from a person who leaves a valid will. There is no forced share for a spouse or a child in the Succession Law Reform Act, and no rule that children take equally. That freedom is what makes a fara'id distribution enforceable: a court gives effect to the shares because you directed them, not because it recognises the framework behind them. So the document has to state the shares in terms an estate trustee can apply.
The Court of Appeal for Ontario showed how far the freedom reaches in Spence v BMO Trust Co, 2016 ONCA 196. Where a will is unambiguous and makes an outright gift, evidence of why the testator chose those beneficiaries is not admissible to strike the gift down on public policy grounds. The application judge had voided the will on evidence of a motive most people would find repugnant. The Court of Appeal restored it, and the Supreme Court refused leave.
That is not a guarantee, and nobody should sell it as one. Spence concerned an unconditional gift. Gifts made conditional on something — remaining Muslim, marrying within the faith, a particular observance — raise a different and much less settled question. Ontario courts have struck religious and racial restrictions out of charitable trusts on public policy grounds, and conditions in private gifts can fail for uncertainty. Give the shares outright and keep conditions out of the instrument.
Part V of the Succession Law Reform Act lets a dependant — a spouse, parent, child, or sibling of the deceased who was being supported, or was owed support, immediately before death — apply for support out of the estate regardless of the will. Child reaches a grandchild and a person you showed a settled intention to treat as a child of your family, so a stepchild, or a child in your care, can qualify where classical fara'id gives them nothing. The court decides what adequate provision means.
The claim also reaches past the estate. For support purposes the Act treats the deceased's interest in jointly held property, insurance proceeds paid to a named beneficiary, and designated registered plan proceeds as though they were still estate assets. Routing wealth around the will does not put it beyond reach. The application runs six months from the certificate of appointment, after which a court may still allow it, but only against what remains undistributed.
The second claim is the spousal election. A married surviving spouse need not take what the will gives them. Within six months of the death they may elect an equalization of net family property under the Family Law Act instead, filed with the Estate Registrar for Ontario. Electing revokes the gifts the will made to them, and after a long marriage with a house the equalization payment is often far larger than a fixed share. Nothing may be distributed in that window without their written consent or a court order, except reasonable advances to dependants of the deceased for their support.
Under the Succession Law Reform Act a will must be in writing, signed by you at its end, and witnessed by two people who were both present when you signed and who then sign in front of you. Ontario permits witnessing by audio-visual link and signing in counterpart, provided at least one witness is a licensee of the Law Society of Ontario. A will wholly in your own handwriting and signed by you needs no witnesses at all.
Who witnessed it matters as much as how many. A witness who takes a gift under the will, or whose spouse does, loses that gift unless the court is satisfied neither exercised improper or undue influence. The will survives; the gift does not. This is the usual defect in wills signed informally at a mosque or in a family home, where two of the friends who witnessed are also named beneficiaries. Re-signing with independent witnesses takes an afternoon. Fixing it after death takes a court application.
Capacity is not defined in the Act. It comes from the case law, and it is judged at the moment you signed. Nothing in the Succession Law Reform Act requires a will to be in English or French, though a court application will need a certified translation of an Arabic or Urdu document. Where a writing fails the formalities but genuinely records testamentary intentions, the Superior Court of Justice can be asked to validate it — an application with cost and delay, and one that cannot rescue an electronic will.
A will made abroad can still be formally valid here. Sections 34 to 42 of the Succession Law Reform Act say that as regards the manner and formalities of making a will of movables or of land, the will is good if when it was made it complied with the internal law of the place where it was made, where you were then domiciled, where you then had your habitual residence, or of which you were then a national. What follows the land is its essential validity and effect: a flat in Lahore or Cairo passes under the law of that place, which may apply its own inheritance rules whatever your Ontario will says.
Where you own property in more than one country, separate wills for the separate jurisdictions is usually right, each drafted so it does not revoke the other. A standard revocation clause in a new Ontario will can wipe out a foreign will by accident, and the family finds out when the foreign estate cannot be administered.
The largest assets often never reach the will. A jointly held home passes by survivorship; registered plans and insurance pass to whoever is named on the designation. If those are meant to follow the will's distribution, the designations have to be aligned deliberately or the estate named, with the tax and probate consequences priced first. One thing worth saying plainly: we draft to your instructions. Whether a distribution satisfies your religious obligation is for your imam or a scholar you trust, not for this firm.
Yes, provided the document satisfies the Succession Law Reform Act. Ontario has no forced heirship, so a court enforces your shares because you directed them, not because they are Islamic. That distinction has a practical edge: the will must set out who takes what, or the formula for working it out, in terms a trustee can apply without asking anyone. Validity also does not put the estate beyond a dependant's support claim or a married spouse's election.
Not on that basis alone. Spence v BMO Trust Co, 2016 ONCA 196 holds that a court will not go behind an outright gift in a clear will to examine motive. What an adult daughter can do is claim dependant support under Part V if you were supporting her or owed her support, or attack the will on the ordinary grounds — capacity, undue influence, faulty execution, want of knowledge and approval. Unequal shares are not a ground in themselves, though they can form part of the picture where a beneficiary arranged the will.
The execution may well be fine — two witnesses present at the same time, signing after you, is what the Act requires. The usual problem is who they were. If either witness, or a witness's spouse, is named to take something under the will, that gift is void unless a court is satisfied there was no improper or undue influence. The rest of the will stands, but that beneficiary loses out. Have it reviewed; re-executing costs a fraction of the application needed to save it.
It depends on whether the marriage is recognised under Ontario law, which turns on how and where the ceremony was performed. A marriage validly contracted abroad is generally recognised here. A religious-only ceremony performed in Ontario that did not comply with the province's marriage legislation is harder, and Ontario decisions have not all gone the same way. Treat the point as live rather than settled before you build a will on either assumption — the equalization election is open only to married spouses.
Open your file tonight — a licensed Ontario lawyer will confirm everything with you by tomorrow.