- - One or more meetings between the child and a trained interviewer - A focus on eliciting the child's own perspective, in an age-appropriate way, without either parent present - A report…
- A full assessment — often called a Section 30 assessment, after the provision of Ontario's Children's Law Reform Act that authorizes it — goes considerably further: - Separate interviews…
When parents disagree about parenting arrangements, Ontario family courts have more than one way to learn what the child themselves thinks and needs. Two of the most common tools — a Voice of the Child Report and a full custody and access assessment — get confused often, but they serve different purposes, involve different professionals, and fit different kinds of cases.
This guide lays out the difference so you know what to expect, and what to ask about, in your own case.
The Core Difference at a Glance
| Voice of the Child Report | Custody and Access Assessment | |
|---|---|---|
| Main purpose | Relays the child's own views and preferences to the court | Evaluates parenting capacity and recommends an overall arrangement |
| Who conducts it | Often a clinician connected with the Office of the Children's Lawyer, or another qualified professional | A psychologist, social worker, or other qualified assessor |
| Scope | Narrower — focused on what the child says, in the child's own words as much as possible | Broader — includes interviews, observation, and analysis of both parents |
| Does it make a recommendation? | Generally reports the child's views without weighing in on the outcome | Typically includes specific recommendations about parenting arrangements |
| When it's used | Cases where the court wants the child's perspective without a full assessment | Higher-conflict cases needing a full evaluation of parenting capacity |
What a Voice of the Child Report Involves
- One or more meetings between the child and a trained interviewer
- A focus on eliciting the child's own perspective, in an age-appropriate way, without either parent present
- A report that generally summarizes what the child said, rather than offering a recommended outcome
- Used partly to give the child a voice in a process about their own life, without putting them in the position of "choosing" between parents in open court
What a Custody and Access Assessment Involves
A full assessment — often called a Section 30 assessment, after the provision of Ontario's Children's Law Reform Act that authorizes it — goes considerably further:
- Separate interviews with each parent, not just the child
- Assessment of each parent's capacity, strengths, and challenges
- Direct observation of parent-child interaction in some cases
- A written recommendation about decision-making responsibility, parenting time, or other arrangements
Which One Might a Judge Use in Your Case
- A Voice of the Child Report tends to fit cases where the parenting dispute is relatively contained, but the court or the parents would benefit from hearing directly from an older child about their preferences
- A full assessment tends to fit cases involving deeper conflict, concerns about a parent's capacity, or a need for a comprehensive, professional recommendation rather than just the child's stated views
- Courts can, and often do, order neither — many parenting disputes are resolved through negotiation, mediation, or a judge's decision on the existing evidence, without either tool
Which option — if any — makes sense for your situation depends heavily on the child's age, the nature of the conflict, and what specific information the court actually needs. This is a question to work through with your family lawyer rather than assume from the outset.
What Happens to the Report Afterward
Once either type of report is filed, it generally becomes part of the court record and is shared with both parents' lawyers, and often the parents themselves, subject to any specific restrictions a judge imposes. It can be used in negotiations, help settle the case without a trial, or be entered as evidence if the matter proceeds to a hearing. Because these reports can shape how a case unfolds, it's worth talking to your lawyer in advance about how the results might be used, and what your options are if you disagree with what a report says.
Frequently asked questions
Does a young child have to participate in either process?
Very young children are less likely to be directly interviewed in either process; how a child's age affects what's appropriate is generally left to the professional conducting the report or assessment, in consultation with the court.
Can both a Voice of the Child Report and a full assessment happen in the same case?
It's possible, though not typical — courts generally try to use the tool that fits the specific gap in the evidence, rather than ordering both as a default. Ask your lawyer whether your case might call for more than one.
Who pays for these reports?
Cost arrangements vary by report type and are often addressed specifically in the order authorizing it, or negotiated between the parties. Speak with your lawyer about what's typical in your court.
Is a child's stated preference binding on the judge?
No. A child's expressed views are one factor a judge considers under the best-interests test, weighed against the child's age and maturity and everything else in the case — not a binding instruction the court must follow.
This is a family law question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed Ontario lawyer before a dollar is owed.