- The court decides whether the will makes adequate provision for the maintenance and support of a spouse or child, so your evidence should show your circumstances and your relationship with the will-maker.
- The court may accept the evidence it considers proper about why the will-maker made or did not make a gift, and it weighs any statement of reasons against all the surrounding circumstances.
- Start gathering records early, because the claim must be started within 180 days of the grant being issued in British Columbia.
If you think a will leaves you too little, the hard part is often proving it. A wills variation claim is built on documents and on people's accounts of what happened, and a well-organized file makes it easier for you and your lawyer to see how strong the claim is.
This page is a working checklist of what claimants commonly collect: financial records, the history of the relationship, and testimony. It does not explain the legal test in depth, and what matters in your case depends on the facts, so a lawyer should confirm what to gather.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
What your evidence is trying to show
Only a spouse or child of the will-maker can bring a wills variation claim. The court may order the provision it thinks adequate, just and equitable out of the estate if the will does not make adequate provision for the proper maintenance and support of a spouse or children.
The Supreme Court of Canada has said this standard is measured by legal obligations, meaning what the law would have required of the will-maker during life, and by moral obligations, meaning what a judicious person would do by contemporary community standards. Where the estate cannot meet every claim, legal obligations generally come before purely moral ones. Your evidence should therefore speak to both: what you needed and were owed, and what a fair-minded parent or spouse would have done.
Financial records to gather
Financial evidence shows your needs and the size of the estate. Collect what you can, and note what you cannot get so your lawyer can ask for it.
- Your recent income tax returns and notices of assessment
- Pay stubs, benefit statements or pension statements showing your current income
- A list of your monthly expenses, such as housing, food, transportation and medical costs
- Statements of your savings, debts, loans and other assets
- Records of any health conditions, disability or reduced ability to earn income
- Records of money or help you received from the will-maker during their life, and money you gave to them
- Anything you can find about the estate: a copy of the will, property records, account statements and any estate asset list
Be complete rather than selective. Records that do not help you are still part of the picture, and leaving them out can hurt your credibility.
Family history and estrangement
The will-maker's reasons for a gift, or for leaving you out, are often central. The court may accept the evidence it considers proper about those reasons, and when it weighs a statement of reasons it must consider all the circumstances from which a reasonable inference can be drawn about whether the statement is accurate. A will-maker's explanation is therefore not the end of the matter. It can be tested against the record.
- A timeline of your relationship with the will-maker, including moves, illnesses and major family events
- Cards, letters, emails, text messages and social media messages, including ones that show contact and ones that show conflict
- Photos, calendars or travel records that show visits and time spent together
- Records of care you gave, such as driving to appointments, household help or time off work
- Any letter, note or recording from the will-maker explaining their wishes
- Earlier wills or drafts you know about, if you can lawfully obtain them
If there was a falling out, write down honestly what happened and when. The court may refuse an order to a person whose character or conduct, in its opinion, disentitles them to relief. Facing difficult facts early lets you and your lawyer plan for them.
Testimony and witnesses
Documents rarely tell the whole story, so think about who can speak to it. Possible witnesses include other family members, friends, neighbours, caregivers, doctors and people who dealt with the will-maker in their final years. Ask yourself what each person actually saw or heard, rather than what they believe.
- Write a short, dated summary of what each person could say, without coaching them
- Note who may favour the beneficiaries, since their accounts will also be heard
- Keep your own account consistent with the documents you have
- Do not delete messages or throw away records, even unhelpful ones
If you also doubt that the will itself is valid, for example because of capacity, signing formalities or undue influence, that is a separate question with its own evidence, and a lawyer can help you sort out which route fits your facts.
Practical next steps
A wills variation claim must be started within 180 days from the date the grant is issued in British Columbia. A copy of the initiating pleading must be served on the executor no later than 30 days after that period expires, unless the court extends the time for service. Because gathering records can take weeks, begin before the grant is issued if you can.
If the will-maker had minor children, or a spouse or child of the will-maker is mentally incapable, the Public Guardian and Trustee must also be served, or the claim will not be heard. A personal representative must not distribute the estate within 210 days after the grant is issued unless the court orders otherwise, or unless all beneficiaries with an interest in the estate and all persons who may bring a Division 6 wills variation proceeding consent.
- Sort your records into financial, relationship and witness folders
- Make a list of missing documents and who might hold them
- Write your own timeline while memories are fresh
- Note the date the grant is issued and the deadlines that follow from it
- Book a meeting with a wills and estates lawyer to review your evidence
Frequently asked questions
Does a statement from the will-maker explaining their decision decide the case?
No. The court may accept evidence about the will-maker's reasons, but it must consider all the circumstances from which a reasonable inference can be drawn about whether the statement is accurate. Your own evidence can show where the explanation does not match the facts.
Can my past conflict with the will-maker defeat my claim?
It can matter. The court may refuse an order to a person whose character or conduct, in its opinion, disentitles them to relief. How much weight conflict gets depends on the facts, so get advice on your situation.
Do I need proof of financial need?
Financial records are usually the most direct way to show your circumstances. The claim turns on whether the will makes adequate provision for proper maintenance and support, so income, expenses, assets and health records are commonly gathered.
What if I cannot get all the records before the deadline?
Start the claim on time and keep collecting evidence. The claim must be started within 180 days from the date the grant is issued. A lawyer can advise how missing records can be requested once the proceeding is underway.
Sources
- Wills, Estates and Succession Act, SBC 2009, c 13, s 60 (BC Laws) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Tataryn v. Tataryn Estate, [1994] 2 SCR 807, 1994 CanLII 51 (SCC) — canlii.org
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.