- Under WESA s. 158(3), the court may, subject to the will, remove or pass over a person it considers should not act, and the listed grounds include being unable or unwilling to perform duties in a way that hampers administration of the estate.
- A person with an interest in the estate can apply to the court to remove or pass over a personal representative.
- Short of removal, you may be able to press for accounts, test the executor's pay, or ask for leave to act for the estate.
Many executors wear more than one hat. The person managing the estate may also be a beneficiary, a creditor who says the estate owes them money, or someone who wants to buy a house or shares from the estate. That overlap is common, and it is not automatically improper. It does, however, put the executor's own interest next to a duty to act fairly for everyone else.
If you are a beneficiary watching this happen, the question is usually not whether a conflict exists but whether it has reached the point where the court should step in. This article walks through how the court's removal power is framed, what lesser steps are available, and how to prepare before you apply to anyone.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
A conflict is not the same as a ground for removal
In British Columbia, a person who has an interest in an estate may apply to the court to remove or pass over a person entitled to act as personal representative. The court may do so, subject to the will, if it considers the person should not act.
The grounds the statute lists include refusing to act without renouncing, incapacity, a conviction for dishonesty, an undischarged bankruptcy, and being unable or unwilling to perform duties in a way that hampers administration of the estate. A conflict of interest is not named as its own ground in that list. How this applies to a conflict depends on your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer.
The will matters too. The court's power to remove or pass over a person is subject to the will, so what the will says about who should act is part of the picture. Removal as personal representative also does not by itself remove that person as trustee of any trust under the will, which needs separate relief.
Three common conflict situations
- The executor is also a beneficiary: this is very common and often unremarkable, but tension can arise when the executor makes choices, such as timing or valuation, that favour their own share.
- The executor is also a creditor: the executor may be deciding whether to pay their own claim, which is hard to separate from their duty to the other beneficiaries.
- The executor wants to buy estate property: the executor sits on both sides of the sale, so the price and how it was set become the key questions.
In each case, the useful questions are practical. Was the decision disclosed to you? Was the value tested by an independent appraisal or open market exposure? Did the executor keep records showing why the decision was fair? Silence or refusal to explain often tells you more than the conflict itself.
What the court can do if it steps in
Removal is one outcome. The court may also pass over a person, which means granting probate or administration to someone with lower priority than the person passed over. When the court removes or discharges a personal representative, it must appoint a substitute who consents to act, unless administration is complete or a new appointment is unnecessary. The former representative's grant is revoked, and the substitute takes over the former representative's authority and duties.
Two limits are worth knowing. Removal as personal representative does not by itself remove the person as trustee of any trust under the will, which needs separate relief. And where a creditor applies relying on the dishonesty-conviction or bankruptcy grounds, the statute limits those applications to claims above a prescribed amount.
Where special circumstances make it appropriate, the court may also appoint any person it considers appropriate as administrator, on conditions or not, and for general, special or limited purposes. An executor can also ask to be discharged from the role, which is a different route from being removed.
Steps short of removal
Court removal is a large step with costs and risk. Several tools can address a conflict without it.
- Accounts: executors, administrators and trustees under a will generally must obtain an order for passing their first accounts within two years of the grant or appointment, subject to exceptions in the Trustee Act. If a beneficiary serves notice requiring it, accounts must be passed annually, within one month of the anniversary. A trustee who fails to pass accounts as required may be called before the court to explain why.
- Pay: an executor may be allowed a fair and reasonable allowance not exceeding 5% of the gross aggregate value of the estate. The court may, on application, settle the amount of the compensation. This does not apply where the will itself sets the allowance.
- Acting for the estate: with leave of the court, a beneficiary can sue on the estate's behalf to recover property owed to the deceased, or defend proceedings against the estate. Leave depends on reasonable efforts to get the representative to act, notice to the required parties, good faith, and the proceeding being necessary or expedient to protect the estate.
- Relief for the executor: if a trustee may be personally liable for a breach of trust but acted honestly and reasonably, the court may relieve them wholly or partly of that liability. Whether this relief is available to a particular executor depends on the facts of their situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer.
What to do next
- Write to the executor asking, in plain terms, what decisions involve their own interest and for supporting records.
- Keep copies of every response, or note any refusal to respond.
- Ask whether any sale of estate property was valued independently and at what price.
- Note the dates you learned of each concern, because time limits can run from discovery.
- Speak with a lawyer before applying to the court, so you can weigh removal against lesser steps.
If no suitable person is willing or able to administer, the Public Guardian and Trustee may sometimes step in, and anyone aware of an estate needing administration can refer it. It may decline an estate whose assets cannot cover funeral costs and its fees, usually wants consent from all or most known beneficiaries, and does not resolve family disputes over who should administer.
Frequently asked questions
Can an executor be removed just because they are also a beneficiary?
Being a beneficiary is not one of the listed grounds for removal. The court looks at whether the executor is unable or unwilling to perform their duties in a way that hampers administration, among other grounds. The facts of what the executor actually did matter most.
Who can apply to remove an executor?
A person having an interest in the estate may apply to the court to remove or pass over a person entitled to act as personal representative. That generally includes beneficiaries, but whether you qualify depends on your own situation, so confirm it with a lawyer.
What happens to the estate if the executor is removed?
The court must generally appoint a substitute who consents to act, unless administration is complete or a new appointment is unnecessary. The former representative's grant is revoked and the substitute takes over their authority and duties.
If the executor is removed, are they also removed as trustee?
Not automatically. Removal as personal representative does not by itself remove the person as trustee of any trust under the will, which needs separate relief.
Sources
- WESA s. 158(2) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Trustee Act, RSBC 1996, c. 464, s. 99 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Public Guardian and Trustee of BC, Referring an estate to the PGT — trustee.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.