- A citation lets a person interested in the estate require a named executor to apply for probate, and the executor must respond within 14 days after service.
- Proof in solemn form is a court trial or hearing on whether the will is valid, and it ends a notice of dispute about that will.
- A wills variation claim accepts that a will exists and asks the court for more provision, while a validity challenge asks whether the will should stand at all.
You may believe a will is not the real wishes of the person who died. Perhaps you doubt they understood what they signed, or you question how the document was signed. In British Columbia, a person interested in the estate can serve a citation requiring a named executor to apply for probate, and the court can pronounce for the will's validity in solemn form after a trial or hearing.
This article explains two of those tools, a citation and proof in solemn form, and how they differ from a wills variation claim. The details turn on your facts and the deadlines are strict, so a lawyer can confirm what fits your situation.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
Two different questions: is the will valid, or is it fair?
People often use "challenging a will" to mean two quite different things. A validity challenge says the will should not count at all, for example because the will-maker lacked capacity or the signing rules were not followed. A wills variation claim accepts the will but asks the court to change what it gives.
Under section 60 of the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA), the court may order that provision it thinks adequate, just and equitable be made out of the estate if the will does not make adequate provision for the proper maintenance and support of the will-maker's spouse or children. Only a spouse or children can bring that claim. Who may raise a validity challenge depends on your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer.
| Question | Wills variation claim | Validity challenge |
|---|---|---|
| What it asks | Whether the will makes adequate provision for a spouse or child | Whether the will is valid at all |
| Who can bring it | Only a spouse or child | Confirm with a lawyer |
| Time limit | Proceeding started within 180 days of the grant | Confirm with a lawyer |
What a citation does
A citation is a court document in Form P32. A person interested in the estate may personally serve it on each named executor, requiring them to apply for probate. It is useful where the executor has not moved, and you want the will tested rather than left untouched.
- A cited person must respond within 14 days after service.
- The response is made on Form P33, called an Answer to citation.
- A cited person may be deemed to have renounced executorship.
A citation does not by itself decide whether the will is valid. It moves the executor to act, or out of the way. What happens after that depends on the facts and the court's directions.
What proof in solemn form means
Proof in solemn form means the court pronounces for the force and validity of the will after a trial or hearing. This is different from the usual path, where a grant is issued on an application. If you dispute the will, solemn form is the stage at which your concerns are heard by a judge.
It also connects to the notice of dispute. A notice of dispute is filed before the earlier of the issue of an authorization or of the estate grant. While it is in effect, the registrar must not issue an estate grant. It stops being in effect one year after filing, unless renewed, or earlier if it is withdrawn, removed by court order, or the will is proved in solemn form. So a will proved in solemn form ends a notice of dispute about it.
Grounds that may support a validity challenge
- Capacity and age: a person who is 16 or older and mentally capable of doing so may make a will, and a will made without capacity can be challenged as invalid.
- Formalities: the will must be in writing and signed at its end by the will-maker, or the signature acknowledged, in the presence of 2 or more witnesses present at the same time, and then signed by 2 or more of them in the will-maker's presence.
- Undue influence: if you show another person was in a position where the potential for dependence or domination was present, the party defending the will or gift must prove that no undue influence was exercised.
A will that misses the formalities is not necessarily lost. Under section 58 of the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA), the court may order that a record or document, including electronic data, is fully effective as the will-maker's will, or as a revocation, alteration or revival of a will, even though it does not comply with the Act.
What to do next
- Search Court Services Online under probate and caveat/dispute cases, using all or part of the deceased's last name, to see whether a file or dispute already exists.
- Note whether you received a notice of proposed application in Form P1; the application cannot be made until at least 21 days after it is delivered.
- Gather the will, any earlier wills, and records about the will-maker's health and the signing.
- Ask a lawyer promptly whether a notice of dispute, a citation, or a wills variation claim fits your position, because the deadlines differ.
Frequently asked questions
Can I serve a citation on any executor?
A person interested in the estate may personally serve a citation on each named executor. Whether you count as interested depends on your connection to the estate, so confirm it with a lawyer.
How long does an executor have to respond to a citation?
A cited person must respond within 14 days after service. A cited person may be deemed to have renounced executorship.
Does a notice of dispute stop probate?
Yes, while it is in effect the registrar must not issue an estate grant for that estate. It lapses one year after filing unless renewed, among other ways it can end.
Can I bring both a validity challenge and a wills variation claim?
They answer different questions, so some people consider both. A wills variation claim must be started within 180 days from the date the grant is issued in British Columbia, so get advice early.
Sources
- Wills, Estates and Succession Act, SBC 2009, c 13, s 60 (BC Laws) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Supreme Court Civil Rules, BC Reg 168/2009, Rule 25-10(1) (BC Laws) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Supreme Court Civil Rules – probate forms, Province of British Columbia — www2.gov.bc.ca
- CSO Help – Search by Deceased Name, Government of BC — justice.gov.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.