TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Home/Calculators/Refinance Break-Even Calculator
№ vRefinancing · Ontario

Does refinancing actually pay off?

A lower rate isn't automatically a win once you count the penalty and closing costs of refinancing. Enter your numbers below to see how many months it takes for the monthly savings to cover what refinancing costs.

Quick answer: Refinancing a $420,000 balance from 5.34% to 4.19% saves about $264 a month — but against $12,500 of penalty plus $1,900 in costs, it takes roughly 55 months, about 4.6 years, to break even. If you won't keep the new mortgage that long, the numbers may not favour switching. Enter your own figures below.
✓Break-even shown in months✓Penalty & closing costs included✓Payment comparison, plain and simple
№ v.1Find Your Break-Even

Your break-even point, estimated

Enter your balance, old and new rate, remaining amortization, and the penalty and other costs of refinancing.

A lawyer discharges the old mortgage and registers the new one on closing. See what a refinance closing involves →.

Want a lawyer to check this? Book a 20-minute call with a real estate lawyer — $150, HST included, credited in full toward your file once payment is received.

This is a 20-minute call. We cover as much as we can and stop at twenty minutes. If more is needed, we will say what the next step is and what it would cost.

Ask about your result

Have a question about this estimate? Send us a message — our Team will get back to you.

№ v.2What Goes In

What counts as the cost of refinancing

Add these up before comparing rates alone.

Refinancing usually means paying out your existing mortgage — which can trigger a prepayment penalty if it's a closed mortgage — plus new costs to set up the replacement: an appraisal, a discharge fee from your old lender, and legal fees to register the new charge and pay out the old one. Only once you add those up do you know what the lower rate actually needs to recover.

The calculator above treats the time it takes your monthly savings to cover that total as the break-even point — a useful test against how long you actually expect to keep the new mortgage.

№ v.3What This Doesn't Capture

A payment comparison, not the whole picture

Two things this estimate leaves out.

This compares monthly payments only. It doesn't account for a longer amortization resetting your payoff date further out, or for any extra equity you take out as part of the refinance — both of which change the real cost-benefit picture beyond the monthly number.

A straightforward refinance also needs a lawyer: the new mortgage has to be registered on title and the old one discharged, and land transfer tax does not apply to a refinance on a property you already own.

№ v.4Worked Example

A $420,000 balance, from 5.34% to 4.19%

Current payment (5.34%, 22-year remaining amortization)$2,693.40
New payment (4.19%, same amortization)$2,429.61
Monthly saving$263.78
Penalty ($12,500) plus other costs ($1,900)$14,400
Months to break even55

Run your own number — any balance, rates, amortization, penalty or costs — in the calculator above; it uses the exact same math.

№ v.kKnow the Words

Key terms

Break-even pointHow many months of monthly savings it takes to recover the penalty and closing costs of refinancing — the shorter, the sooner refinancing pays for itself.
Prepayment penaltyThe charge for paying out a closed mortgage early, usually the larger cost in a refinance. See our mortgage penalty calculator for your own estimate.
RefinanceReplacing your existing mortgage — with your current lender or a new one — at new terms, which a lawyer closes by discharging the old charge and registering the new one.
Discharge feeA fixed fee, usually a few hundred dollars, that a lender charges to release its charge on title when a mortgage is paid out.
№ v.6Before You Ask

Common questions

Does refinancing trigger Land Transfer Tax?

No. Land Transfer Tax applies to a change of ownership — a purchase. Refinancing a mortgage on a property you already own doesn't trigger it.

What closing costs come with a refinance?

Typically a discharge fee from your old lender, an appraisal fee, and legal fees to register the new mortgage and discharge the old one — the "other costs" figure in the calculator above. Any prepayment penalty on the old mortgage is usually the larger cost.

What if the new payment isn't actually lower?

Then there's no monthly saving to recover the costs from, and refinancing at those numbers doesn't pay for itself on payments alone — the calculator above will tell you plainly when that's the case.

Should I refinance now or wait for renewal?

It depends on your penalty, the rate gap, and how long you'd keep the new mortgage — exactly what this calculator estimates. If your penalty is small or your term is nearly up, waiting for renewal is often the simpler comparison; see our renewal calculator.

Run this on your site

Free to embed, no sign-up. See the embed snippets →

Ready to talk it through?

Book a 20-minute call with a real estate lawyer — $150, HST included, credited in full toward your file once payment is received.

This is a 20-minute call. We cover as much as we can and stop at twenty minutes. If more is needed, we will say what the next step is and what it would cost.

What clients say

In their own words

“The e-signing setup meant I didn't have to take time off work to get papers signed.”

T.I. · Home purchase · Barrie

Shared with permission. Initials changed to protect client privacy.

Read more reviews →

These are estimates for planning. They are not legal advice and they do not create a solicitor-client relationship. Last reviewed 23 September 2026.

Message usBook a 20-min call →Book a call →