TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Licensed by the Law Society of OntarioFlat fees published upfrontWe reply to messages within 1 business daySign in
Papers and a pen on a wooden desk beside a laptop
Treadstone Perspectives

Prices are softer but mortgage rates are higher: a first-time buyer's reading of CREA's September report

CREA says prices are lower than a year ago and that a jump in fixed rates makes things harder for prospective buyers as it relates to a mortgage.

BuyingMortgagesCanada-wide

Photo: 2H Media on Unsplash

← All Perspectives

The short version

  • Prices are lower than a year ago: CREA's index is down 3.4%, and the average sale price is down 1.6%.
  • CREA also points to a jump in fixed mortgage rates, which its chair says makes the task harder for prospective buyers as it relates to a mortgage.
  • For a first purchase, the monthly payment is the number to test, not the headline price.

Two things in one report

Buying your first home means reading mixed signals. CREA's September report, released on October 16, 2026, gives you both kinds. The national average sale price was $666,538, which is lower than a year earlier. That figure is a Canada-wide average, and CREA warns that it does not account for price differences between areas.

-3.4%MLS Home Price Index, year over year
4.9months of inventory nationally
48.8%sales-to-new-listings ratio, September

Sources: CREA, Canadian Home Sales Pull Back in September (October 16, 2026); CREA National Statistics, September 2026

What the rate part of the story says

CREA's chair says the start of the fall market met an even larger jump in fixed rates, which is harder for prospective buyers as it relates to a mortgage. The same statement says it will also likely mean more homes to choose from and more negotiating power.

The release, dated October 16, said the Bank of Canada was widely expected to follow with a rate hike before the end of the year. On October 28 the Bank of Canada increased its target for the overnight rate by 25 basis points to 2.5%. The Bank's rate is not your mortgage rate, but a pre-approval you were quoted before that date is worth confirming with your lender.

Sources: CREA, Canadian Home Sales Pull Back in September (October 16, 2026); Bank of Canada, press release, October 28, 2026

Questions to settle before you start looking

Inventory of 4.9 months sits between CREA's benchmarks of 3.6 months (a seller's market) and 6.4 months (a buyer's market). A first-time buyer in a given city may see something quite different, so find your local board's own report.

  • Ask your lender what rate they would use today to qualify you, and for how long that rate and approval are held.
  • Work out the monthly payment at that rate, not at the rate you saw last spring.
  • List the cash you need at closing beyond the down payment, and ask your lawyer to explain each item.
  • Ask whether any first-time buyer rebates apply to the home you are considering, and get the rules from the official page, not from hearsay.
  • Decide in advance which offer conditions you want, such as financing and inspection, before a particular house puts you under pressure.

CREA's figures also show more homes listed than a year ago: active listings were slightly more than 200,000 at the end of September, up 1.8%, while actual sales activity was 7.7% below September 2025. More listings across the country do not mean more homes in your price range or your town, so the count is only a prompt to look at your own market.

This is general information from public sources, not legal or financial advice. It does not predict where prices or rates will go.

Sources: CREA National Statistics, September 2026; CREA, Canadian Home Sales Pull Back in September (October 16, 2026)

Same news, your situation

This is general information, not legal advice.
ContactStart a File →