A management buyout is the cleanest exit a private owner can have. The buyer already knows the business, so diligence is short and the story to staff and customers writes itself. The hard parts are money and conflict — you are negotiating against people you owe duties to.
Our charges include applicable taxes. Disbursements are extra and billed at cost — itemized upfront, in writing, never hidden.
From $3,388.87 taxes included
The managers incorporate a new company, and that company buys either the shares or the assets. Shares are usually better for the seller, because a capital gain on qualifying small business corporation shares may attract the lifetime capital gains exemption. Assets are usually better for the buyer, because the buyer gets a fresh cost base and does not inherit the corporation's history. The price should reflect which one you chose.
Funding almost always comes from three or four places. The managers put in equity, which is often less than they expect to need. A bank or BDC provides senior debt secured under the Personal Property Security Act, usually with personal guarantees. The seller takes back a vendor note for part of the price, subordinated and postponed to the bank under a formal agreement between the two lenders. Sometimes a minority equity partner fills the gap.
A vendor take-back is normal and it changes the negotiation. The seller is now both vendor and lender, and cares about how the business is run until the note is paid — expect covenants on distributions, salaries and further borrowing, and expect the seller to want a board seat or information rights. Deferred consideration and earnouts do similar work. Life insurance funding the note is cheap protection for both sides.
A manager who is also a director owes the corporation a fiduciary duty and a duty of care under section 134 of the Business Corporations Act, and must disclose any interest in a material contract or transaction under section 132. Generally that director does not vote on the transaction. This is not a formality — it is the difference between a clean deal and one that is unpicked in court two years later by a shareholder who was not in the room.
The seller needs independent advice, and where there are shareholders outside management, the process needs to be visibly independent. The real risk in an MBO is not price, it is information: management knows things the shareholders do not, and buying on that basis is precisely the fact pattern that produces oppression claims under section 248 of the OBCA. Agree an information protocol at the outset — what management may use, what must be disclosed, and a standstill while the bid is prepared.
For a public company, MI 61-101 treats a management buyout as an insider bid or business combination and requires a formal valuation and majority-of-the-minority approval. Private companies are not caught by that instrument, but the underlying logic — independent valuation, an independent process, full disclosure — is exactly what a court will look for if the deal is later challenged. Doing it voluntarily is cheap insurance.
If the seller sells shares that qualify as small business corporation shares, the lifetime capital gains exemption may shelter a substantial part of the gain. Qualification is tested, not assumed, and depends on what the company owns, what it does, and how long the shares have been held. Purification — moving surplus cash and passive assets out so the company qualifies — takes time. It should be done well before a deal, not during one.
Section 84.1 of the Income Tax Act is the trap. Where an individual sells shares to a corporation with which they do not deal at arm's length, the capital gain can be converted into a deemed dividend, destroying the exemption. In an ordinary MBO to unrelated managers this does not bite, because the parties are at arm's length. Where a manager is a family member, it very much does — and specific intergenerational transfer rules apply to a genuine transfer to a child or grandchild, with conditions that must be planned for before the new company is even incorporated.
Employee ownership trusts are now in the Income Tax Act as an alternative route for owners who want to sell to their workforce rather than to a management group. The rules are detailed and the qualifying conditions are strict. If broad employee ownership is the actual goal rather than a management group taking control, it is worth pricing both structures before committing.
Two managers who agree on everything today will not agree on everything in five years. The shareholders' agreement is the most important document you will sign after the purchase agreement: board composition, what decisions need unanimity, deadlock resolution, drag-along and tag-along rights, a shotgun clause, and leaver provisions setting the price for someone who resigns, is dismissed for cause, or dies. Vesting on the founding managers' shares is worth considering where one of them may not stay.
Get a non-competition covenant from the departing owner. The Employment Standards Act, 2000 has prohibited non-compete agreements in employment contracts since 25 October 2021, but section 67.2(3) expressly exempts a covenant given by a seller who becomes an employee of the buyer as part of a sale of a business, and section 67.2(4) exempts executives. Sale-of-business covenants are also assessed more permissively by the courts than employment ones: Payette v Guay inc., 2013 SCC 45.
Then insure the risk you have just concentrated. Key-person insurance on each of the new owners, life insurance sized to the vendor note, and a buy-sell mechanism in the shareholders' agreement that says what happens to a deceased owner's shares. All three are cheap at the start of a buyout and impossible to arrange in the middle of a crisis.
More than you would like and less than the price. Lenders want to see the management team meaningfully at risk, and a seller taking back a note wants the same thing — if the managers have nothing invested, they can walk away from a bad year. Beyond that there is no formula. The gap between what the managers can fund and what the bank will lend is what the vendor note, the earnout or an equity partner is for. Work out those numbers before you approach the owner.
To a degree, and it is standard practice — surplus cash reduces the purchase price, and the operating company's assets typically secure the acquisition debt. But the directors still owe duties to the corporation, and loading a company with debt it cannot service exposes them personally and can be attacked by creditors if the business later fails. Do the solvency analysis honestly before closing and record it. This is a point to work through with the lender and your accountant together.
If you are a director or a senior officer, yes — and early. You owe a fiduciary duty to the corporation, and section 132 of the OBCA requires disclosure of your interest in a transaction. Assembling a bid quietly while using company information and company time is how an MBO turns into litigation. The disclosure conversation is also the practical one: an owner who feels ambushed usually stops the process, while one brought in at the start usually helps finance it.
They are the people most likely to sue, so build the process around them. Independent valuation, an independent director or committee reviewing the transaction, full disclosure of what management knows, and identical terms for every shareholder of the same class. If the shareholders' agreement has a drag-along, check what it lets you force them to sign. If it does not, you need either their agreement or a structure that does not require it.
Three to six months is typical from serious conversation to closing, and financing is the long pole. Diligence is faster than a third-party sale because the buyers already know the business, but lenders still need financial statements, projections and security, and the seller's tax planning may need lead time. Where the seller's shares need purifying to qualify for the capital gains exemption, start that conversation with the accountant first — it can add months.
Open your file tonight — a licensed Ontario lawyer will confirm everything with you by tomorrow.