Family arbitration is a private hearing with a decision-maker you choose, and the award binds you the way a court order does. Ontario puts four conditions on it. Miss one and the award you paid for may be worth nothing.
Our charges include applicable taxes. Disbursements are extra and billed at cost — itemized upfront, in writing, never hidden.
From $1,693.87 taxes included
In arbitration you and the other party appoint an arbitrator, agree what they may decide, and agree to be bound by the result. Unlike mediation, nobody has to agree at the end. The arbitrator hears evidence and issues a written award, and a family arbitration award can be filed with the court and enforced in the same way as an order made by a judge.
That finality is the trade. You are giving a private decision-maker authority over property, support or your children's schedule, and your ability to appeal is limited to what the arbitration agreement and the Arbitration Act, 1991 allow. Negotiate appeal rights at the front end, in writing, when you still have leverage. Nobody negotiates them well after an award they dislike.
The advantages are real. You pick an arbitrator who actually knows family law, you set the hearing date instead of waiting for one, you can arbitrate a single narrow issue rather than the whole file, and the process is private. Court files, by contrast, are public records. For families with a business, a public record is itself a cost.
The most common structure in Ontario is mediation-arbitration: the same neutral first tries to mediate, and arbitrates only what does not settle. It saves time and repeat explanation, but it means the person who heard your settlement positions will decide the case. That is a legitimate choice, and it needs to be a deliberate one. Our comparison of <a href="/articles/mediation-vs-arbitration-vs-court-ontario-comparison">mediation, arbitration and court</a> lays out the differences.
First, timing. Under the <a href="https://www.ontario.ca/laws/statute/90f03">Family Law Act</a>, a family arbitration agreement is unenforceable unless it is made after the dispute to be arbitrated has arisen. An arbitration clause buried in a marriage contract, signed years before anyone disagreed about anything, does not bind you. Couples are often surprised by this, because commercial contracts work the opposite way.
Second, independent legal advice. Each party must get advice from their own lawyer before signing the arbitration agreement, and an award made without it is unenforceable. This is not a formality to be waived because you both feel reasonable today. It is the condition most often missing when an award gets attacked, and the cheapest one to satisfy.
Third, screening. The parties must be screened separately for power imbalances and family violence, and the arbitrator has to take the screening into account throughout. Fourth, governing law: a family arbitration must be conducted exclusively under the law of Ontario or of another Canadian jurisdiction. An arbitration under religious or foreign law is not a family arbitration in Ontario and produces nothing the court will enforce.
There is a narrow exception for secondary arbitration — arbitrating a question that a separation agreement, a court order or an existing award already says may be arbitrated, such as an annual support adjustment. There, the agreement is allowed to predate the dispute, and the parties do not need fresh independent legal advice each time. Everything else follows the four conditions above.
Arbitration suits parties who need a decision on a defined issue, quickly, from someone who understands the subject matter — a business valuation, a support recalculation, a parenting schedule that keeps failing on the details. It works badly where one party will not disclose finances honestly, because an arbitrator has fewer blunt tools than a judge for compelling production and punishing non-compliance.
Screening exists for a reason. Where there is family violence or a serious power imbalance, a private process without the structure of a courtroom can entrench the imbalance rather than correct it. A properly trained arbitrator will decline the file rather than proceed. Our article on <a href="/articles/mediation-screening-family-violence-ontario">screening for family violence</a> explains what that screening looks like.
Decisions about children stay reviewable. An award affecting parenting is still measured against the child's best interests, and the court's protective jurisdiction over children does not disappear because the parents signed an arbitration agreement. Similarly, arbitrated child support has to respect the guidelines. Arbitration changes who decides and how fast — it does not create a private zone outside family law.
Treadstone acts as counsel in family arbitrations, prepares and reviews arbitration agreements, and provides the independent legal advice the other side's arbitration agreement requires. Family matters are quoted as flat fees — the uncontested divorce is $1,693.87, taxes included — with the list on our <a href="/pricing">pricing page</a>. For background, read <a href="/articles/family-arbitration-ontario-what-to-expect">what to expect in a family arbitration</a> and <a href="/articles/enforcing-family-arbitration-award-ontario">how awards get enforced</a>.
Yes, provided it is a valid family arbitration. The award is filed with the court and enforced through the same machinery as an order, including support enforcement. That is exactly why the conditions matter: an agreement signed before the dispute arose, or without independent legal advice, can leave you holding an award the court will not enforce.
You can write one, but it will not bind you. Ontario makes a family arbitration agreement unenforceable unless it is entered into after the dispute to be arbitrated has arisen. If you want arbitration later, you sign a fresh arbitration agreement at the time. The exception is secondary arbitration of matters an existing agreement or award already provides for.
Yes. Each party must receive independent legal advice before signing the family arbitration agreement, from a lawyer who acts only for them. An award made without it is unenforceable. Independent legal advice is a discrete, flat-fee service, and getting it is far cheaper than litigating whether the award survives.
Only within limits. Your appeal rights are largely what the arbitration agreement sets out, within the framework the Arbitration Act, 1991 allows, and a court can also set an award aside on defined grounds such as arbitrator bias or a process failure. Decide the appeal rights when you draft the agreement, not after the award lands.
The hearing is private and the award is not a public court record, which is the main reason business owners and people with public roles choose it. Confidentiality still depends on what the arbitration agreement says, so have that clause drafted deliberately. Enforcement in court can put some material on the public record.
Open your file tonight — a licensed Ontario lawyer will confirm everything with you by tomorrow.