TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Home/Tax/Paying Yourself Properly, and Keeping the Structure
№ iTax · Ontario

Paying Yourself Properly, and Keeping the Structure Right

Most owner-manager tax planning comes down to four decisions: how you pay yourself, whether you need a holding company, who else owns shares, and when you cap the growth in your own hands. Get those right and most of the rest is bookkeeping.

Transparent flat-fee pricing

Our charges include applicable taxes. Disbursements are extra and billed at cost — itemized upfront, in writing, never hidden.

From $563.87 taxes included

All Tax services

Salary or dividends

The Canadian system is built so that income earned through a corporation and paid out to you ends up taxed at roughly the same total rate as income you earned personally. That is integration, and it means the salary-versus-dividend question is rarely about the headline rate. It is about the side effects.

Salary is deductible to the corporation, creates RRSP contribution room, counts toward CPP, and supports a mortgage application. It also costs both halves of CPP and requires payroll remittances on a schedule the CRA enforces harshly. Dividends carry no CPP and no payroll administration, but build no RRSP room and no CPP entitlement, and must come out of income the corporation has already paid tax on.

Most owner-managers end up with a mix, sized to keep corporate income at or under the small business limit and to fund personal cash needs. The right mix changes when corporate income crosses the limit, when you want maximum RRSP room, and when a sale of the business is on the horizon.

Who else can own shares

Splitting income with a spouse or adult children used to be straightforward. The tax on split income rules changed that: dividends paid to a family member are taxed at the top personal rate unless an exclusion applies, regardless of what that person's own income is.

The workable exclusions are narrow. A family member who works in the business an average of 20 hours a week is generally excluded. So is a shareholder aged 25 or over holding excluded shares — broadly, a substantial percentage of votes and value in a corporation that is not a professional corporation and earns most of its income from an unrelated business. A spouse aged 65 or over can receive amounts that would have been excluded had the owner received them.

Family shareholdings still matter even where dividends are constrained, because each individual has their own lifetime capital gains exemption available on a future share sale. That is often the stronger reason to have them on the register in the first place.

Holding companies, and what they actually do

A holding company lets you move retained earnings out of the operating company as intercorporate dividends, generally tax-free between connected corporations, putting accumulated cash beyond the reach of the operating business's creditors. It also helps keep the operating company's balance sheet clean for the capital gains exemption.

It does not save tax by itself. Investment income earned inside the holding company is taxed at a high rate up front, with a portion refunded when taxable dividends are paid out. Two accounts are worth understanding: the capital dividend account, which lets the non-taxable half of capital gains and life insurance proceeds flow out to you tax-free, and the general rate income pool, which supports eligible dividends taxed at a lower personal rate.

There is real administration attached — a second set of financial statements, a second corporate return, separate annual filings. For a company with little surplus cash and no meaningful creditor exposure, it is usually not worth it yet.

Freezing the value, and passing it on

An estate freeze converts your growth shares into fixed-value preferred shares and issues new common shares to the next generation or to a family trust. Your tax exposure on death is capped at today's value, future growth accrues to them, and their exemptions become available on a later sale. It is done on a rollover basis, so nothing is triggered at the time.

Selling your business to your own children was, for years, punished: section 84.1 recharacterised the proceeds as a dividend, so a sale to a stranger was taxed more favourably than a sale to your daughter. That was changed in 2021 and tightened again in 2023, and genuine intergenerational transfers can now qualify for capital gains treatment under either an immediate or a gradual transfer route, each with its own conditions on control, management and timing.

The general anti-avoidance rule was strengthened in 2024, with a penalty and reporting obligations attached. Structures that exist only to produce a tax result, with no real change to how the business actually operates, carry more risk than they did five years ago.

How it works

  1. Set the remuneration mix before year end, not at filing time — payroll remittance deadlines are unforgiving.
  2. Review the share register: who holds which class, and whether family shareholdings survive the split income rules.
  3. Decide whether retained earnings justify a holding company, and if so, transfer on a tax-deferred basis.
  4. Check the capital dividend account balance before declaring any dividend — tax-free room is easy to miss.
  5. If the business is growing and succession is on the horizon, price out an estate freeze now rather than later.
  6. Flat fee for the initial legal consultation: $563.87, taxes included.

Common questions

Should I pay myself salary or dividends?

Usually both. A common approach is enough salary to create RRSP room and cover CPP, with the balance taken as dividends. The answer shifts with your corporate income level, whether family members hold shares, whether you need mortgage-qualifying income, and how close you are to selling. It is a decision to revisit every year, not a permanent setting.

Can I pay my spouse dividends to lower our combined tax?

Only where an exclusion from the tax on split income rules applies. The main routes are working in the business an average of 20 hours a week, holding excluded shares at age 25 or over, or being the spouse of an owner aged 65 or over. Paying dividends to a spouse who does not work in the business and holds a small nominal shareholding will generally be taxed at the top rate.

Do I need a holding company?

If the operating company has meaningful retained earnings you want protected from business creditors, or you are preparing the balance sheet for a share sale, probably yes. If it is a young business with no surplus cash, it is extra filings for no benefit. Revisit the question once retained earnings become significant.

When is the right time for an estate freeze?

Before the growth happens, which is the opposite of when most owners think about it. A freeze caps your value at today's number, so it is most valuable when you expect the company to be worth substantially more later. Doing it after the value has already accumulated locks in a large deemed disposition on death.

Ready to begin?

Open your file tonight — a licensed Ontario lawyer will confirm everything with you by tomorrow.

Prefer to talk first? Call 1-844-900-1070 — it’s free.
ContactStart a File →