TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Home/Case Studies/Wills & Estates
№ 64 Case Study — Wills & Estates

A Tech Executive's First Will Had to Cross Two Borders

Herman had never made a will. Between a North York condo, vested stock options, and a family apartment overseas, dying without one would have handed a Singapore court and an Ontario court two conflicting problems to solve at once.

Wills & Estates6 min readNorth York, OntarioMaking a first will
All Wills & Estates case studies
ClientHerman, a technology executive in North York with assets in Canada and overseas
The issueNo will, and property in two countries with different succession rules
ServiceFirst will, with cross-border asset planning
ResolutionA completed Ontario will, paired with a separate foreign will, that keeps both estates out of conflict

The situation

Herman was 42, a technology executive living in North York, and he had never made a will. He had moved to Canada from Singapore in his late twenties, built a career at a software company, bought a condo, and settled into the kind of life that made estate planning feel like a problem for later. Later arrived sooner than he expected. His father died the previous year, and Herman inherited a family apartment in Singapore outright, along with a modest investment account held at a bank there. He was single, with no children, and his closest relationships were his brother Raymond, who owned and operated several franchise locations across the GTA, and a longtime friend and former business partner, Arjun, who still held a passive interest in a technology venture Herman had co-founded years earlier.

The inherited apartment forced the question Herman had been avoiding. He now had meaningful assets in two countries with two different legal systems, and no instructions anywhere for what should happen to any of it. He came to Treadstone Law wanting a straightforward first will. What he got was a plan that had to work in Ontario and stay out of the way of a second estate process eight thousand kilometres away.

What the review found

The first step was an inventory of everything Herman owned, in every currency. In Ontario, that meant the North York condo, worth roughly $950,000, a portfolio of vested and unvested stock options and RRSP holdings worth close to $1,100,000, and a further $750,000 in non-registered investment accounts. In Singapore, the inherited apartment was worth roughly $1,200,000 in Canadian-dollar terms, plus a smaller investment account. Altogether, Herman's estate sat at around $4,000,000.

Without a will, Ontario's Succession Law Reform Act would decide who inherited the Canadian assets. That statute sets out a fixed order of relatives entitled to an intestate estate, and for someone without a spouse or children, it generally flows to parents, then siblings. Herman assumed that meant Raymond would simply inherit everything, and in Ontario that assumption was roughly right. But it left no role at all for Arjun, no instructions about who should manage the estate, and no say for Herman over how or when Raymond received it. An intestate estate also needs a court-appointed estate trustee before anyone can act, which adds delay at exactly the moment family members are least equipped to handle it.

The Singapore apartment raised a separate issue entirely. Property located outside Canada is generally governed by the succession law of the country where it sits, not by an Ontario will's general language. A will drafted in Ontario that purported to gift "all my property, wherever situated" could still leave the Singapore apartment tied up, because a Canadian grant of probate is not automatically recognized by authorities or land registries overseas. Worse, if Herman later signed a separate will in Singapore to deal with the apartment, a poorly worded Ontario will could unintentionally revoke it, or vice versa, since a new will generally revokes any earlier one covering the same property unless it is drafted to expressly carve out what it does not touch. Herman needed two wills that were aware of each other, not two wills that quietly cancelled each other out.

What we did

  1. Mapped the estate by jurisdiction, not by asset type. We separated Herman's holdings into a Canadian estate and a foreign estate, because each would eventually be administered under different rules, by different professionals, using different documents.
  2. Drafted an Ontario will limited to Canadian assets. The will was written to expressly apply only to property located in Canada, so it would not touch, and could not accidentally revoke, a separate will made to deal with the Singapore apartment. This is the same drafting approach used when someone holds Canadian assets that should pass without probate alongside other assets that require it — the wills are drafted to coexist rather than overlap.
  3. Talked through executor choice honestly. Herman's instinct was to name Raymond as estate trustee because he was family. We walked through what the role actually involves — locating assets, paying debts and taxes, filing the estate's final tax returns, distributing to beneficiaries — and how that workload sits alongside running several franchise locations. Herman ultimately named Raymond as primary estate trustee with Arjun as an alternate, giving the estate a backup if Raymond was unable or unwilling to act when the time came.
  4. Set out specific and residual gifts. Rather than one gift to one person, the will named Raymond as the primary beneficiary of the Canadian estate but included a specific bequest to Arjun reflecting their history together, along with a contingency plan naming a charitable beneficiary if both Raymond and Arjun predeceased Herman with no other named beneficiary alive.
  5. Flagged the deemed disposition on death. Under the Income Tax Act, a person is treated as having disposed of most capital property immediately before death, which can trigger tax on accrued gains in non-registered investments. Employee stock options carry their own separate tax rules that also needed a specialist's attention on death. We did not attempt to solve this inside the will itself, but made sure Herman's estate trustee would know to obtain tax advice promptly rather than distributing assets before the estate's final tax position was clear.
  6. Referred Herman to counsel in Singapore for the foreign will. We are not licensed to advise on Singapore succession law, and said so plainly. What we could do was draft the Ontario will to leave room for a Singapore will to operate independently, and give Herman a clear written summary of what the foreign will needed to state — most importantly, that it applied only to Singapore assets — so the lawyer he engaged there could draft with the Ontario document already accounted for.
  7. Added powers of attorney for property and personal care. Since Herman had no will at all, he also had no documents naming anyone to manage his affairs or make health decisions if he became incapable. We prepared both at the same time, naming Raymond with Arjun as alternate, so the planning gap did not stay half-closed.

The outcome

Herman signed a completed Ontario will, along with powers of attorney for property and personal care, within a few weeks of his first meeting with our team. The will named Raymond as estate trustee, set out clear gifts to both Raymond and Arjun, and was drafted narrowly enough to sit alongside a future Singapore will without conflict. Herman engaged a lawyer in Singapore several weeks later to draft a will covering the apartment and the local investment account, using the summary we had prepared to make sure the two documents lined up rather than overlapped.

The practical difference is significant. If Herman dies today, his Canadian estate passes according to his actual wishes rather than a fixed statutory formula that would have written Arjun out entirely. His estate trustee does not need to apply to a court simply to get authority to act, because a validly signed will and a named estate trustee, once probated, is a far more direct process than an intestacy. And the Singapore apartment is governed by a will drafted specifically for that jurisdiction, by a lawyer qualified to draft it, rather than by an Ontario document reaching for a country it was never built to reach.

None of this changed how much Herman is worth or how much tax his estate will eventually owe. What it changed is who decides what happens to it, and how much friction his executor and beneficiaries face when that day comes. For a first will, that was the whole point.

What you can learn from this

  • If you own assets in more than one country, a single will rarely covers all of them properly — foreign real estate is generally governed by the law of the country where it sits, not by the general wording of a Canadian will.
  • Multiple wills should be drafted to expressly limit their own scope. A later will can unintentionally revoke an earlier one covering different property unless it says clearly that it does not.
  • Dying without a will does not mean your estate goes to the government — it means a statute decides your beneficiaries for you, and that formula may not match who you actually want to provide for.
  • Naming an executor is not just picking a family member you trust. Consider their actual capacity to take on months of administrative work, and name a backup in case they cannot.
  • A first will is a good moment to add powers of attorney for property and personal care at the same time — they cover incapacity while you're alive, which a will does not address at all.
This case study is entirely fictional. It does not describe any real client, file, or matter handled by Treadstone Law, and it is not a real file with details changed. All names, people, properties, businesses, dollar amounts, dates, and events are invented, and any resemblance to a real person, business, or situation is coincidental. Fictional scenarios like this one illustrate the kinds of legal issues people in Ontario commonly face and how a lawyer can help. They are general information, not legal advice — no two matters unfold the same way, and nothing here predicts the outcome of any real case. Reading a case study does not create a lawyer-client relationship. If you are facing something similar, speak with a lawyer about your specific circumstances.

This is a wills & estates problem we handle

Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.

ContactStart a File →