- You tell the RPD you no longer wish to pursue your claim, perhaps because your circumstances changed, you found another way to remain in Canada, or you've decided to return home voluntarily.
- It's a finding the RPD makes about you, generally triggered when a claimant fails to move the case forward — missing a hearing without a satisfactory explanation, failing to file a…
Not every refugee claim ends with a decision on the merits. Some claims are withdrawn by the claimant, and others are declared abandoned by the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) when a claimant stops pursuing the case. These sound similar, but they're legally different events with different consequences, and mixing them up can leave you unprepared for what happens next.
Withdrawing a Claim
Withdrawal is something you do. You tell the RPD you no longer wish to pursue your claim, perhaps because your circumstances changed, you found another way to remain in Canada, or you've decided to return home voluntarily. Depending on the stage your claim has reached, the RPD may need to be satisfied that the withdrawal is genuinely voluntary before accepting it, particularly once a hearing is already underway.
Abandoning a Claim
Abandonment works differently. It's a finding the RPD makes about you, generally triggered when a claimant fails to move the case forward — missing a hearing without a satisfactory explanation, failing to file a required document like the Basis of Claim form, or becoming unreachable. Before declaring a claim abandoned, the RPD generally gives the claimant an opportunity to explain the failure at an abandonment hearing. If the explanation doesn't satisfy the member, the claim is declared abandoned.
Key Differences at a Glance
| Withdrawal | Abandonment | |
|---|---|---|
| Who initiates it | The claimant | The RPD, based on the claimant's conduct |
| What it signals | A voluntary choice to stop pursuing the claim | A failure to pursue the claim diligently |
| Is an explanation considered? | Not usually needed — it's your choice | Yes, you're generally given a chance to explain first |
| Can it be refused? | Sometimes, particularly mid-hearing | N/A — it's the RPD's own finding |
Consequences That Follow You
Both outcomes end the claim without a decision on whether you actually qualify for protection, and both can affect you going forward.
- No RAD appeal. Withdrawn and abandoned claims are generally excluded from an appeal to the Refugee Appeal Division — there's no merits decision to appeal.
- Effect on future claims and other processes. A withdrawn or abandoned claim can affect eligibility for certain future applications and can be relevant to how later immigration matters are assessed.
- Removal exposure. Once a claim ends without protection being granted, you may no longer have a basis to remain in Canada, and removal processes can follow.
What an Abandonment Hearing Generally Looks Like
If the RPD is considering declaring your claim abandoned, you're generally scheduled for a hearing specifically to address that question before any final decision is made. This is your opportunity to explain what happened — a missed notice, a change of address that wasn't updated, illness, or another genuine obstacle. The member weighs your explanation against the pattern of conduct in your file. Showing up prepared, with documentation supporting your explanation where possible, matters far more here than it might seem, because once a claim is declared abandoned, reversing that finding is difficult.
If You've Missed a Step
If you've missed a hearing, a deadline, or a document filing, don't assume the claim is automatically lost. An abandonment finding generally isn't automatic — there's usually a chance to explain, and a well-supported explanation matters. Acting immediately, rather than waiting to see what happens, gives you the best chance of keeping your claim alive. If you're not sure where things stand, a quick check-in through our Ask a Lawyer page is a low-pressure way to get pointed in the right direction.
Frequently asked questions
Can I change my mind after withdrawing my claim?
Generally, once a withdrawal is accepted, it's difficult to reverse. Think carefully, and get advice, before formally withdrawing rather than after.
What counts as a good explanation for missing a hearing?
This depends heavily on the facts — illness, a missed notice, or a genuine misunderstanding are the kinds of things that get considered, but there's no guaranteed list of acceptable reasons. Document whatever happened and raise it immediately.
If my claim is declared abandoned, can I make a new refugee claim later?
Not automatically, and in many circumstances it's restricted. This is exactly the kind of situation where the general rule and your specific facts can diverge significantly, so don't assume either way without advice.
Is withdrawing my claim the same as giving up on staying in Canada?
Not necessarily. Some people withdraw a refugee claim because they've found a different immigration pathway. But withdrawal ends that specific claim permanently, so it shouldn't be done without understanding what other options you do or don't have.
This is an immigration question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed Ontario lawyer before a dollar is owed.