- A time is of the essence clause signals that the parties meant a date to be taken seriously, but how strictly a court enforces it depends on the exact wording and the facts.
- Some dates in a business sale come from statute, not from your contract, such as the GST/HST election filing date.
- If a closing date has slipped, act quickly, keep records and get legal advice before you terminate or demand anything.
You signed an agreement to buy or sell a business, and a date has come and gone. Maybe the money was late, a landlord has not signed off, or a document was not ready. Now someone points to a clause that says time is of the essence and says the deal is over.
This article explains in plain words what that kind of clause is meant to do, why the answer is rarely automatic, and which deadlines in a Newfoundland and Labrador sale come from legislation rather than from your contract.
This article covers the law of Newfoundland and Labrador.
What the clause is trying to do
A time is of the essence clause says that the dates in the agreement are central to the deal, so that missing one is serious. Without it, parties often have more room to argue that a short delay can be fixed. With it, the party who is ready to close may say the other side's delay lets them walk away.
How strictly a deadline is enforced can turn on the exact wording of your agreement and on what happened between the parties around the closing date. How this applies depends on your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer before you rely on the clause or treat a missed date as ending the deal.
Dates the law sets, whatever your contract says
Some timing rules do not depend on a clause at all. They apply because of legislation, and a missed date can have a cost even if the agreement is silent.
| Date or period | Where it comes from | Why it matters in a sale |
|---|---|---|
| GST/HST election filing | Excise Tax Act, s. 167 | A registrant buyer must file the election by the due date of its return for the first period in which tax would otherwise be payable, unless the Minister allows a later date. |
| Notice before ending a job | Labour Standards Act, ss. 52 and 55 | Written notice is required within the period set by section 55. |
| Group termination notice | Labour Standards Act, s. 57 | An employer intending to terminate 50 or more employees within a 4-week period must give 8, 12 or 16 weeks of written notice, depending on the number of employees. |
| Company annual return | Registry of Companies | A late return makes the company NOT IN GOOD STANDING. |
| Name reservation | Commercial Registration Division | An online name reservation is held for 90 days. |
The GST/HST election under section 167 of the Excise Tax Act is worth a closer look. The seller and buyer can jointly elect that no GST/HST is payable on the sale of a business, if the buyer acquires all or substantially all of the property reasonably necessary to carry on the business. Tax is still payable on a taxable supply of a service the seller will render, on a taxable supply of property by lease, licence or similar arrangement, and, if the buyer is not a registrant, on a taxable sale of real property. The election is not available where the seller is a registrant and the buyer is not. The filing date is the one the law sets: a registrant buyer must file by the due date of its return for the first reporting period in which tax would otherwise be payable, unless the Minister allows a later date on application. Missing it is a deadline problem that no contract clause can cure on its own.
Dates inside the deal that can cause real harm if they slip
Many closing conditions depend on third parties, so a delay is not always one side's fault. Each of the following can move a closing date.
- Landlord consent: a tenant may not assign the leased premises during the term without the landlord's written consent, which is not to be arbitrarily or unreasonably withheld. That covenant applies as an implied term only where the lease uses the statutory wording, so the actual lease must be read.
- Rent arrears: where half a year's rent is in arrears, a landlord may start a proceeding to recover possession without a formal demand or re-entry. The proceeding stops if the tenant pays the arrears and costs before trial. These forfeiture rules are the commercial-lease rules and do not apply to residential premises governed by the Residential Tenancies Act, 2018.
- Tax lien: unpaid tax is a first lien in favour of the Crown on the entire assets of the taxpayer's estate, and it continues until paid or until the minister issues a clearance certificate. Waiting on a certificate can hold up closing.
- Security interests: a buyer of business assets should search the registry for interests the seller gave over equipment, inventory or receivables, because a perfected interest can follow the asset.
If your agreement makes time of the essence, a delay in any of these steps may be argued to be a breach by whoever was responsible for it. Whether it was, and whether the deadline was truly strict, depends on who had to do what under the agreement.
Employees and ownership: a date does not reset service
A closing date also marks the change of owner. Where an employer transfers its undertaking to another person or firm, an employee's employment with the new owner is treated as continuous with the employment with the first employer. An undertaking includes a business carried on by an employer, so this applies to a sale of a business. A late or failed closing therefore matters to staff, who keep their service if the sale completes.
What to do if a deadline has been missed
- Find the clause and every date it covers, including any amendments or extensions.
- Write down who was responsible for each outstanding step and what actually happened.
- Gather emails and letters showing whether anyone agreed to move the date or kept working toward closing.
- Check whether you were ready, willing and able to close on the date yourself.
- Do not send a termination notice, refuse to close, or demand a deposit back until a lawyer has reviewed the agreement.
- Ask your accountant about any tax filing date, including the GST/HST election, that may also be at risk.
Bring the signed agreement, any schedules and the correspondence. How the deadline wording in your agreement applies, and whether the date can still be saved, depends on your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer.
Frequently asked questions
Does a time is of the essence clause always let me cancel the deal if the other side is late?
No. Its effect depends on the wording, the dates it covers, and how both parties acted. It also matters whether you were ready to close yourself. Have a lawyer review the agreement before you cancel.
Can we agree to move the closing date?
Parties can usually agree in writing to change a date, and doing so clearly avoids later arguments. If you do, say whether time remains of the essence for the new date. Have a lawyer draft the amendment.
Does a missed closing date affect the GST/HST election?
It can. A registrant buyer must file the election by the due date of its return for the first reporting period in which tax would otherwise be payable, though the Minister may allow a later date on application. Speak to your accountant promptly.
What if a landlord is slow to consent to the lease assignment?
Where the statutory covenant applies, consent is not to be arbitrarily or unreasonably withheld. Whether it applies depends on the lease wording. Raise the delay in writing and get advice on your lease.
Sources
- Labour Standards Act, RSNL 1990 c L-2 (House of Assembly) — assembly.nl.ca
- Revenue Administration Act, SNL 2006 c R-15.01 (House of Assembly) — assembly.nl.ca
- Excise Tax Act, s. 167 (Justice Laws) — Justice Laws (federal)
- Personal Property Security Act, SNL 1998 c P-7.1 — assembly.nl.ca
- Conveyancing Act, RSNL 1990 c C-34 — assembly.nl.ca
- Commercial Registration Division FAQ, Government of NL — gov.nl.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a buying & selling a business question
Buying or selling a business with us is from $3,448.85, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.