- Refinancing usually means breaking your current mortgage, and the penalty is typically the higher of three months' interest or the interest rate differential.
- A second mortgage leaves your first mortgage alone, but you keep paying both and the rate on the second is usually higher.
- Neither option is cheaper in every case, so compare the penalty, the new rate and the fees side by side before you commit.
You need a lump sum for renovations, debts or a family expense, and your home is the obvious source. The question is whether to leave your first mortgage in place and add a second one, or to replace the first mortgage with a larger new one.
The answer turns on two costs that pull in opposite directions: the penalty for ending your current mortgage early, and the higher rate that usually comes with a second loan. This article walks through both so you can compare them.
Two ways to get cash, two different cost drivers
A refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a new, larger one. Because you are ending the old contract early, the cost to watch is the prepayment penalty.
A second mortgage is a separate loan secured on your home. You must keep paying the first mortgage as well, and the interest rate on the second is usually higher because it is riskier for the lender.
The penalty side of refinancing
If you break a mortgage contract, the prepayment penalty is usually the higher of three months' interest on what you still owe or the interest rate differential, often called the IRD. Federally regulated lenders must set out prepayment privileges and penalties in an information box at the start of the mortgage agreement.
Your own contract is the place to start. Find that information box or the prepayment clause, and ask the lender for a written payout figure rather than estimating.
There is also a statutory rule for longer terms. Where a mortgage term is longer than five years, after five years from the mortgage date you may pay off the principal and interest plus three months' further interest in lieu of notice. That right does not apply to a mortgage given by a corporation.
The rate side of a second mortgage
The trade-off for avoiding a penalty is a higher rate on the new money. You can usually borrow up to 80% of your home's value, minus what you still owe, and the home is the security, so you may lose it if you cannot repay.
A second charge ranks behind an earlier registered first charge. Priority can be changed by registering a postponement, so ask whether any lender is expecting that.
Private lenders are common in this market. Private mortgages are generally a short-term option, often for one or two years, are often interest-only, and fees are often higher than for a traditional mortgage; private lenders may also charge fees for late payments, lapsed insurance or property upkeep. Have an exit strategy for how you will repay or replace the loan.
Comparing the real numbers
- Refinance: the penalty on your current mortgage, plus the new rate and fees on the whole balance.
- Second mortgage: the higher rate and fees on the new amount only, while your first mortgage continues unchanged.
- Term and repayment: a short-term, interest-only loan may look cheap monthly but leaves you needing a way out.
- Total cost over the time you actually expect to hold each loan, not just the first year.
A useful way to compare is to add up the one-time costs (the penalty and fees) and then the ongoing interest on each route over the same period. A smaller loan at a higher rate can still cost less than a large refinance with a heavy penalty, and the reverse can also be true.
Checking rates, brokers and fees before you sign
Interest on mortgage arrears cannot be charged at a rate that increases the charge beyond the rate payable on principal not in arrears. It is also a criminal offence to enter into or receive interest at an annual percentage rate above 35 per cent on the credit advanced. Certain commercial loans to borrowers who are not individuals are treated differently.
If a broker arranges the loan, check that they are licensed. Mortgage brokerages, brokers, agents and administrators in Ontario are licensed by FSRA, and you can check a licence on FSRA's public listing, which FSRA says is more reliable than a printed licence. A brokerage must take reasonable steps to make sure any mortgage it presents is suitable for your needs and circumstances, must disclose material risks in writing, must disclose its relationship with each lender and any actual or potential conflict of interest, and must get your written acknowledgement. Those disclosures must be made no later than two business days before you sign.
What to do next
- Get your current mortgage contract and find the prepayment terms.
- Ask your lender for a written payout figure and penalty calculation.
- Collect written quotes for a refinance and for a second mortgage, with all fees listed.
- Confirm any broker's licence on FSRA's public listing.
- Have a lawyer review the documents before you sign, especially for a private loan.
Frequently asked questions
Is a second mortgage always more expensive than a refinance?
No. The rate on a second mortgage is usually higher, but a refinance can bring a prepayment penalty on your existing mortgage. Which costs less depends on your penalty, the amount you need and how long you will hold the loan.
How is the prepayment penalty usually calculated?
It is usually the higher of three months' interest on what you still owe or the interest rate differential. Your mortgage agreement sets out the details.
Do I have to keep paying my first mortgage with a second mortgage?
Yes. A second mortgage is a second loan, and you must keep paying the first one too.
What if the second mortgage lender is a private lender?
Private mortgages are generally short-term, are often interest-only and often carry higher fees, so plan how you will exit the loan and consider independent legal advice before signing.
Sources
- CanLII – Land Titles Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.5 — canlii.org
- Ontario.ca – Postponement of Charge form — files.ontario.ca
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada – Borrowing against home equity — canada.ca
- Justice Laws – Interest Act, s. 8 — Justice Laws (federal)
- Justice Laws – Criminal Code, s. 347 — Justice Laws (federal)
- Justice Laws – Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, SOR/2024-114 — Justice Laws (federal)
- FSRA – Private Mortgages — fsrao.ca
- FSRA – Licensed Mortgage Brokerages, Administrators, Mortgage Agents, and Mortgage Brokers — fsrao.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.