- When an owner, tenant or resident causes the damage, the corporation can charge the owner the lesser of the repair cost or its insurance deductible.
- Some corporations have by-laws that make owners pay the deductible in more situations, including where no one is directly at fault.
- An unpaid chargeback can lead to a lien against your unit, so it is worth checking the bill before ignoring it.
A pipe fails, water runs into the unit below, and weeks later you get a letter from the corporation asking you to pay its insurance deductible. The bill can feel unfair, especially if you did nothing wrong, and the amount can be surprising.
This page is about one question: when is the corporation allowed to pass its deductible on to you? The answer turns on what caused the damage and on what your corporation's own by-laws say.
What the deductible is and why it reaches owners
A condo corporation must carry insurance and never let it lapse, including cover for damage to units and common elements. If damage is caused by an owner, tenant or resident, the corporation can charge the owner the lesser of the repair cost or the corporation's insurance deductible.
Some corporations also have by-laws that make owners pay the deductible in more situations, including where no one is directly at fault. Deductibles can range from a few hundred dollars to tens of thousands. That range is why the rules on who pays matter so much after a leak.
The basic rule when you, a tenant or a resident caused the damage
Under s. 105(2), where damage is caused by an owner, tenant or resident, the corporation can charge the owner the lesser of the repair cost or the corporation's insurance deductible. So if repairs cost less than the deductible, the charge is capped at the repair cost.
This kind of bill is a chargeback, a cost the corporation bills to one owner, usually because of that owner's act or omission. It is separate from your regular monthly fees.
When a by-law can widen the charge
Some corporations have by-laws that make owners pay the corporation's deductible in more situations, including where no one is directly at fault. A leak from a failed fitting that nobody could have prevented might fall under that kind of by-law.
Not every corporation has one. Whether yours does, and how it is worded, is something to read closely rather than assume.
Documents that decide your bill
Ontario condos are governed in this order: the Condo Act, then the declaration, then the by-laws, then the rules, and if they conflict the Act takes priority. A by-law cannot override the Act.
- The by-laws: look for any deductible provision and what situations it covers.
- The governing documents: they define the standard unit, and the corporation repairs damage to it.
- The corporation's invoice: check that it shows the repair cost and the deductible, so you can see which is lower.
- Your own insurance policy: ask whether it responds to a deductible charge.
The corporation's property insurance does not cover improvements or non-standard elements of units, and fixtures, furnishings, equipment and personal property are generally not part of a standard unit, which each corporation defines in its governing documents. The corporation repairs damage to the standard unit as defined there, and owners must repair everything outside that definition, however the damage was caused.
If you dispute or do not pay, and what to do next
If an owner cannot pay chargebacks added to their condo fees and no solution is reached, the corporation automatically has a lien against the unit for that debt. An owner can pay everything secured by the lien at any point until the unit is sold, and the corporation must then discharge it.
A lien tied to an issue within the Condominium Authority Tribunal's jurisdiction can be disputed there, while liens tied to issues outside it, such as repairs, must go to the Superior Court of Justice. Which route applies depends on the facts.
- Ask the corporation in writing for the repair invoice, the insurer's deductible figure and the provision it relies on.
- Read the by-laws and declaration for any deductible clause.
- Check your own policy and tell your insurer about the claim.
- Consider deductible or loss assessment coverage; owners exposed to deductible by-laws may need it.
- Speak to a lawyer before the dispute reaches a lien.
Frequently asked questions
Can the corporation charge me its whole deductible?
Where the damage was caused by an owner, tenant or resident, the charge is the lesser of the repair cost or the deductible. If your corporation has a deductible by-law, it may apply in more situations.
What if nobody was at fault for the leak?
Some corporations have by-laws that make owners pay the deductible even where no one is directly at fault. Whether yours does depends on its by-laws, so read them or ask a lawyer.
Is owner insurance required to cover this?
No statute is cited as requiring owners to carry their own insurance, but a corporation's declaration, by-laws or rules may require it, and then it is mandatory for that building.
What happens if I refuse to pay the chargeback?
If no solution is reached, the corporation automatically has a lien against your unit for that debt. You can end the lien by paying everything it secures before the unit is sold.
Sources
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Common Expenses — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Liens — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Chargebacks — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Insurance — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Contact Us / FAQ — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – Insurance — condoauthorityontario.ca
- Condominium Authority of Ontario – What are governing documents? — condoauthorityontario.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.