- A proposal is not the same as law, so planning around a proposed exemption means planning around wording that can still change.
- Whether two exemptions can be used on the same shares depends on the final legislation and your own facts, so confirm it with an accountant or lawyer before you rely on it.
- How your buyer is financed and how the deal is structured can change with a share sale, for example CSBFP does not finance share purchases.
You own shares in an Alberta corporation that may qualify for the lifetime capital gains exemption. Then you hear about a proposed new exemption for small business shares. You wonder whether you can use both on the same shares, or whether you should hold off selling until the new one arrives.
This page does not set out the detailed rules of either exemption. It helps you frame the decision, shows what to ask your tax adviser, and covers a few other parts of a sale that do not depend on which exemption you use.
This article covers the law of Alberta.
Why the stacking question matters
Whether an exemption on a gain from shares has a limit, and how much gain it can cover, depends on the specific exemption and your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer. If a second exemption existed, the natural question is whether the two add together on the same shares, or whether using one uses up room under the other. The answer sits in the exact wording of each rule, not in a general impression of how they fit.
Many owners assume that two tax breaks aimed at the same gain will not simply double up. That is a reasonable starting expectation, but it is only an expectation. Treat it as something to confirm, not as a conclusion.
A proposal is not yet a rule
Until a proposed measure is passed into law, its details can change. Who qualifies, which shares count, when it starts and how it interacts with existing exemptions can all be adjusted. Planning a sale around a proposal means accepting that risk.
Because of that, it is not safe to assume the proposal will apply to shares you already hold. Whether existing shares are covered, or only newly issued ones, is exactly the kind of detail to check in the current text with your accountant.
Questions to weigh before you wait or act
- Is a sale actually likely in the near term, or are you only exploring options?
- Do your shares clearly qualify for the lifetime exemption today, and would that still be true on the day of a sale?
- Would the proposed exemption plausibly apply to your shares at all, or is it aimed at newly issued shares?
- What happens to your position if the proposal changes or never becomes law?
- Is there a buyer, a deadline or a health or family reason that makes waiting costly?
- Would crystallizing now, meaning deliberately realizing a gain to use the exemption, cost you anything in tax or flexibility?
Waiting can keep options open, but it can also mean losing a sure benefit for an uncertain one. Acting early can lock in a benefit, but it may have side effects. An accountant can model both paths for your numbers.
Other parts of the sale that do not depend on the exemption
Structure matters beyond income tax. In a sale of business assets, each property and service can be treated as a separate supply, so GST at 5% in Alberta can apply to the taxable parts, and Alberta has no provincial sales tax. A joint election between seller and buyer can remove that tax in the right circumstances. A share sale is a different kind of deal, so the asset-sale GST rules should not be assumed to carry over.
Your buyer's financing may also depend on structure. The Canada Small Business Financing Program does not finance share purchases or assets acquired by a holding company, so a share purchase of an Alberta company cannot be funded that way. If your buyer plans to use that program, an asset sale may be what they need. That can pull against the tax result you want, which is why structure should be settled with advisers before price talks go far.
What to do next
- Ask your accountant whether your shares qualify for the lifetime exemption now and what could change that before a sale.
- Ask in writing how the proposed exemption, if enacted, would interact with the lifetime exemption on shares you already hold.
- Check who is recorded as an owner and director of your corporation. Alberta Corporate Registry searches, requested through a registry agent, can show the registration date, owners, directors and legal addresses.
- Ask a lawyer how a share sale compares with an asset sale for you and for your buyer.
- Set a date to review the plan again once the proposal's status is clearer.
Frequently asked questions
Can I combine the proposed new exemption with the lifetime capital gains exemption on the same shares?
Many people expect that two exemptions aimed at the same gain will not simply add together, but the answer depends on the final legislation. Until the rules are enacted and their wording is known, it cannot be confirmed. Ask your accountant to check the current text against your shares.
Should I delay selling until the proposed exemption becomes law?
It depends on how likely the proposal is to apply to your shares, how firm your buyer's timeline is, and what you would give up by waiting. A proposal can change or not proceed. An accountant can compare waiting with selling or crystallizing now.
Does the structure of my sale affect my buyer's financing?
It can. The Canada Small Business Financing Program does not finance share purchases or assets acquired by a holding company. It can finance the eligible assets of an existing business, up to the lower of the purchase price or the appraised value of those assets.
How can I confirm who owns the shares of my Alberta corporation?
Alberta Corporate Registry searches are requested through a registry agent and can show owners, directors and legal addresses. The registry agent charges a government fee plus a service fee. Your corporate records and a lawyer can confirm the rest.
Sources
- Excise Tax Act, s.167 (Justice Laws) — Justice Laws (federal)
- ISED – CSBFP FAQ for small businesses — ised-isde.canada.ca
- Alberta.ca – Find corporation details — alberta.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a buying & selling a business question
Buying or selling a business with us is from $3,148.95, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.