Is a Shore Road Allowance Still a Public Road if It Was Never Opened or Used in Ontario?
No. Years of non-use do not turn an original shore road allowance into private land. Road allowances made by the Crown surveyors that are located in municipalities are highways unless they have been closed, and that includes original shore road allowances. An overgrown strip that nobody has travelled is still a highway in law unless it was closed.
A highway, including an unopened road allowance, is owned by the municipality that has jurisdiction over it. A municipality closes a road allowance by by-law, and the by-law takes effect only when a certified copy is registered in the land registry office. Closing must happen before the allowance can be sold to an abutting owner. So the question is whether a closing by-law was passed and registered, not how long the strip has sat unused.
The rule also runs forward. After January 1, 2003, land can become a highway only by a by-law establishing it. Whether a particular strip lies in a municipality, or was ever closed, depends on the facts, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer through title and municipal records before you buy or build.
Key takeaways
- An original shore road allowance in a municipality is a highway unless it has been closed, however overgrown it looks.
- The municipality that has jurisdiction owns a highway, including an unopened road allowance.
- Closing a road allowance takes a by-law, and the by-law takes effect only once a certified copy is registered in the land registry office.
- After January 1, 2003, land can become a highway only by a by-law establishing it.