TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Licensed by the Law Society of OntarioFlat fees published upfrontWe reply to messages within 1 business daySign in
Learn/Ask a Lawyer/British Columbia/What Happens in British…
Wills & Estates

What Happens in British Columbia if Siblings Disagree Over Who Should Be Committee for a Parent?

TSL Written by the Treadstone Law Team· Updated November 21, 2026

This answer covers the law of British Columbia.

Whether you can apply and be appointed depends on your situation and on what your siblings object to, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer. The court may appoint any person as committee of a patient, and while no other committee is appointed the Public Guardian and Trustee is the committee.

If your parent signed a written nomination of committee while of full age and sound mind, executed like a will, the court must appoint that nominee unless there is good and sufficient reason to refuse. Where family members compete, the Public Guardian and Trustee reviews the choice and qualification of the proposed committee, whether security such as bonding is needed, and whether the medical evidence is sufficient, then files a Response to Petition with the court.

Your siblings may also argue that your parent is not incapable. If incapacity is in dispute, the court may direct an issue to be tried and may order examination by other medical practitioners. The Public Guardian and Trustee calls a committee a last resort after other options have been explored. Exactly what your siblings can file, and how a judge ranks competing candidates, depends on the facts, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer.

Key takeaways

  • The court may appoint any person as committee, and the Public Guardian and Trustee is the committee while no other committee is appointed.
  • A written nomination of committee made while of full age and sound mind carries real weight, because the court must appoint the nominee unless there is good and sufficient reason to refuse.
  • If your siblings dispute that your parent is incapable, the court may direct an issue to be tried or order examination by other medical practitioners.
  • The Public Guardian and Trustee reviews the choice and qualification of the proposed committee and files a Response to Petition with the court.
This is general information, not legal advice. It doesn’t create a lawyer–client relationship, and the rules can change. For advice on your situation, a Treadstone wills & estates lawyer can help.

Go deeper

Sources

Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.

Still have questions?

Search our answers, or send yours to a Treadstone lawyer — we answer in plain language.

All answersStart a File →