Can a person with a guardian or adult guardianship order still have capacity to make a will in British Columbia?
This answer covers the law of British Columbia.
Possibly, yes. How a guardian, a committee or a representation agreement affects the answer depends on the facts, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer. For a will, section 36 of the Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA) says a person aged 16 or older may make one if mentally capable. The Act does not define that test, which comes from case law that BC courts apply together with s. 36.
Banks v Goodfellow (1870) is described as the leading authority on testamentary capacity, still applied about 150 years later. Age and capacity are separate requirements, so being old enough to make a will does not settle capacity either. If a challenger raises suspicious circumstances relating to mental capacity, the person defending the will takes back the legal burden of establishing capacity.
A guardianship order or agreement may be part of the picture, but how much it matters depends on your relative's situation and the other facts, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer. A lawyer can help your family assess how the requirement that a will-maker be mentally capable applies to your relative.
Key takeaways
- Section 36 of WESA lets a person aged 16 or older make a will if they are mentally capable.
- The test for mental capacity comes from case law rather than the statute, and Banks v Goodfellow is described as the leading authority.
- Where suspicious circumstances relate to mental capacity, the person defending the will must establish capacity.
- A guardianship order or representation agreement may be part of the evidence, but its weight depends on the facts, so ask a lawyer how it applies.