TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Licensed by the Law Society of OntarioFlat fees published upfrontWe reply to messages within 1 business daySign in
A calculator on a page of handwritten calculations
Treadstone Perspectives

Selling a cottage or second property: how the principal residence rule treats the gain

The Canada Revenue Agency lets a family name only one home per year as its principal residence, so a cottage and a house compete for the same years.

SellingTaxCanada-wide

Photo: Joachim Schnürle on Unsplash

← All Perspectives

The short version

  • The CRA says a family can name only one home as its principal residence for each year.
  • A cottage and a house therefore share the same set of years.
  • A sale has to be reported on your tax return, even if no tax is owing.

One home per family, per year

Many families own a house and a cottage, or a house and a second property. When one of them is sold, the first question is whether the sale is a taxable capital gain or covered by the principal residence exemption.

The CRA's page on principal residences says a family can name only one home as its principal residence for each year since 1982. For 1993 and later, the family means you, your spouse or common-law partner, and your children, with exceptions the page lists. A spouse who was separated under a court order or written agreement for the whole year is not counted for that year.

You name the home when you sell it, or are treated as having sold it. The page says you may name it for every year you owned and lived in it, but you may choose not to name some years.

If a house and a cottage are both owned for the same years, each year can go to only one of them.

Sources: CRA, Principal residence and other real estate (canada.ca)

What you report when you sell

Since the 2016 tax year, the CRA allows the exemption only if you report the sale and the designation on your return. The page says to report it on Schedule 3, Capital Gains or Losses, and to complete Form T2091(IND). Only page 1 of that form is needed if the home was your principal residence for all the years you owned it, or for all but one.

The page also covers the "plus 1" rule. If you sell one home and buy another in the same year, you can name the home you sold for all years, including the year of sale, even though only one home can be named for that year. The page says you must be resident in Canada in the year the home was purchased.

Two cautions from the same page. A loss on a principal residence cannot be claimed. And a late designation may be accepted in some cases, but a penalty may apply.

  • The years you owned each property
  • Which property you named, or plan to name, for each of those years
  • Who in your family unit owns other property and when
  • Your purchase documents and the sale statement for each property

Sources: CRA, Principal residence and other real estate (canada.ca)

How much of a gain is taxed

When part of a gain is not covered by the exemption, it is a capital gain. The CRA's update, dated January 31, 2025, says it has reverted to administering the currently enacted inclusion rate of one-half. In plain words, one-half of a capital gain is counted as taxable income.

A higher rate was proposed. The CRA page describes an increase from one-half to two-thirds, for dispositions on or after January 1, 2026. Finance Canada's 2026 tax expenditures report says the government confirmed in Budget 2025 that it would not proceed with these changes.

Your own tax rate and the rest of your income decide what a taxable amount costs you, so a number cannot be given here.

Sources: CRA, Update on the CRA's administration of the proposed capital gains taxation changes (canada.ca); Finance Canada, Report on Federal Tax Expenditures 2026, Part 2 (canada.ca)

What to gather and ask

Make a year-by-year listWrite down each year you owned the cottage and the house, and where the family lived.
Ask which property to nameAsk your lawyer or accountant how the designation works for your years before you sign an agreement to sell.
Ask about reportingAsk who will prepare Schedule 3 and Form T2091(IND), and what records they need from you.

This is general information based on public sources, not legal advice. Your own facts decide how a rule applies to you.

Sources: CRA, Principal residence and other real estate (canada.ca); CRA, Update on the CRA's administration of the proposed capital gains taxation changes (canada.ca)

This is general information, not legal advice.
ContactStart a File →