TREADSTONE LAW · ONTARIO · DIGITAL LEGAL SERVICES · EST. MMXXI ·TSL
Licensed by the Law Society of OntarioFlat fees published upfrontWe reply to messages within 1 business daySign in
A stack of papers with a pen on a wooden table
Treadstone Perspectives

Homeowners' replacement cost fell 1.9% in the price index while insurance costs rose 4.9%: what an owner can check

Two housing lines in Statistics Canada's September report point in different directions; here is how to read them as an owner.

BuyingCanada-wide

Photo: 2H Media on Unsplash

← All Perspectives

The short version

  • The homeowners' replacement cost index fell 1.9% year over year in September 2026.
  • Homeowners' home and mortgage insurance rose 4.9% year over year.
  • Your insurer values your house its own way, so ask it for your figure.

Two housing lines that moved apart

The September Consumer Price Index came out on October 19, 2026. Most coverage focused on the headline, which rose 3.1%. For people who own a house, two smaller lines are worth a look.

The release says the homeowners' replacement cost index fell 1.9%, at the same rate as in August. It also says homeowners' home and mortgage insurance rose 4.9% year over year, and it lists that rise among the drivers of faster shelter price growth. Shelter overall rose 1.8%, up from 1.5% in August.

The same section of the release also points to fuel oil and other fuels, up 57.8% year over year, and says the price increase had a greater impact on consumers in Atlantic Canada, where fuel oil is more widely used. It reports rent up 2.8% and the mortgage interest cost index down 0.2%. Those are separate lines from the two this piece looks at.

-1.9%homeowners' replacement cost, year over year
4.9%home and mortgage insurance, year over year
1.2%homeowners' maintenance and repairs, year over year

Sources: Statistics Canada, The Daily: Consumer Price Index, September 2026 (Oct 19, 2026)

Reading these as an owner

These are national price indexes. The release does not explain how either one relates to the rebuilding cost of a particular house, and it gives no Ontario figure for them. It is not a valuation of your property.

A national replacement cost index cannot tell you what it would cost to rebuild your home, and it cannot tell you your coverage limit. Those depend on your house: its age, size, finishes and local trades.

A national index measures prices across the country; it does not measure your house.

Sources: Statistics Canada, The Daily: Consumer Price Index, September 2026 (Oct 19, 2026)

Questions for your insurer and lawyer

  • What replacement cost figure your policy uses, and when it was last updated.
  • Whether your policy pays to rebuild, or only the market value of the house.
  • Your deductible and any limits for water damage or sewer backup.
  • What changed in your premium at the last renewal, and why.
  • If you have a mortgage, what your lender requires you to carry.
Find your declarations pageIt states the coverage limits you actually hold.
Ask the insurer for its reasoningA written answer is easier to compare next year.
Check any paperwork tied to the houseIf you are buying, selling or refinancing, ask your lawyer what the lender and the closing documents require.

This is general information based on public sources, not legal advice.

Sources: Statistics Canada, The Daily: Consumer Price Index, September 2026 (Oct 19, 2026)

Same news, your situation

This is general information, not legal advice.
ContactStart a File →