- WESA s. 52 reverses the onus only after the challenger shows a position of potential dependence or domination.
- Without that showing, the person alleging undue influence or fraud bears the burden of proving it.
- A spouse or child who cannot prove it may have a wills variation claim under s. 60, which has a 180-day limit.
You were left out of a will, or left with little, and you suspect someone pressured the will-maker. But you cannot point to evidence that the will-maker depended on that person or was dominated by them.
That gap matters. This article explains what happens when the onus shift in WESA s. 52 never applies, and when a wills variation claim may be the fallback.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
Why the onus shift may not help you
Under WESA s. 52, if you claim a will resulted from undue influence and show the other person was in a position of potential dependence or domination, the party defending the will must prove no undue influence was exercised.
You carry the first step. You must show that position and that it was used to influence the will. The reversal applies only once you have made that showing. Without it, the ordinary rule applies, and the person alleging undue influence or fraud bears the burden of proving it.
What it means to keep the burden
Suspicion alone is not enough. Even suspicious circumstances that raise a suspicion of fraud or undue influence do no more than rebut the presumption of capacity and of knowledge and approval; a person alleging undue influence or fraud generally still has to prove it, except where s. 52 shifts the onus.
The standard in this area remains the balance of probabilities, even where there are suspicious circumstances. Whether your evidence meets it depends on the facts, and a lawyer can assess it.
The fallback: a wills variation claim
If a will does not, in the court's opinion, make adequate provision for the proper maintenance and support of the will-maker's spouse or children, the court may order provision out of the estate that it thinks adequate, just and equitable. This is an alternative for a disinherited spouse or child who cannot prove incapacity or undue influence.
Spouse status is defined in WESA s. 2: both alive immediately before the relevant time and married or living in a marriage-like relationship for at least 2 years.
| Claim | What you must show |
|---|---|
| Undue influence | Dependence or domination to shift the onus, otherwise proof of the influence itself |
| Wills variation (s. 60) | Inadequate provision for maintenance and support of a spouse or child |
Deadlines to take seriously
- A wills variation proceeding must be commenced within 180 days from the date the representation grant is issued in British Columbia.
- A copy of the initiating pleading must be served on the executor no later than 30 days after the 180-day period, with provision for extensions.
- For the will of a Nisg̱a'a citizen or treaty first nation member, service on the Nisg̱a'a Lisims Government or the relevant treaty first nation is required.
- The 180-day limit applies to wills variation claims, not to every kind of challenge, so timing for a validity challenge should be confirmed with a lawyer.
What to do next
- Write down what you know about the relationship between the will-maker and the beneficiary.
- Find out whether a grant has been issued, and when.
- Diarize the 180-day and 30-day dates for a wills variation claim.
- Consider whether to file a notice of dispute before a grant issues.
- Get legal advice on whether to pursue undue influence, a variation claim, or both.
Frequently asked questions
What if I only suspect pressure?
Suspicion is not proof. Unless you show potential dependence or domination, the onus stays with you to prove undue influence.
Can I bring a wills variation claim instead?
If you are a spouse or child and the will does not make adequate provision for your maintenance and support, the court may order provision from the estate. You do not need to prove undue influence for that claim.
How long do I have for a wills variation claim?
It must be commenced within 180 days from the date the representation grant is issued in British Columbia. The pleading must be served on the executor within 30 days after that period, with provision for extensions.
Can I bring both claims?
That depends on your facts and is worth discussing with a lawyer. The two claims are different, and the wills variation deadline runs separately.
Sources
- Vout v. Hay, 1995 CanLII 105 (SCC) — canlii.org
- Wills, Estates and Succession Act, s. 52 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- BC Government: WESA Part 4 – Wills explanation — www2.gov.bc.ca
- Supreme Court Civil Rules, B.C. Reg. 168/2009, Form P1 and Rule 25-10 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.