- As the person putting the will forward, you carry the legal burden of proving due execution, knowledge and approval, and testamentary capacity.
- If challengers introduce evidence of suspicious circumstances, the legal burden goes back to you, but undue influence stays on them.
- Gathering evidence about how the will was signed and the testator's state of mind early is the most practical way to prepare.
You have been named executor, and a relative is now attacking the will. Being the one who put the will forward means the court looks to you first to show it is valid. That can feel unfair when you are simply doing the job the testator gave you.
This article looks at the dispute from the defender's side. It explains what you must prove, how that task changes if suspicious circumstances are raised, and which part of the fight the challenger must carry.
What you must prove as the person propounding the will
The person propounding a will has the legal burden of proving three things: due execution, knowledge and approval, and testamentary capacity. In plain words, you must show the will was properly signed and witnessed, that the testator knew what it said and approved it, and that the testator had the mental capacity to make it.
If the document was not properly executed, the Superior Court of Justice may still order it valid as the deceased's will if it is satisfied the document sets out the deceased's testamentary intentions. Whether that route fits your case depends on the facts.
What capacity means in a courtroom
Capacity is judged by whether the testator had a sound disposing mind. The testator must understand the nature and effect of the will, recollect the nature and extent of their property, understand what they are giving, remember the people they might be expected to benefit, and, where applicable, understand the claims of those being excluded.
- Understood what a will does
- Knew roughly what they owned
- Understood who was receiving what
- Remembered family members who might expect to benefit
- Understood the claims of anyone left out, where that applies
How the burden moves back to you
Once you prove due execution, the law presumes knowledge, approval and capacity. That puts an evidential burden on the challengers. If they introduce evidence of suspicious circumstances, the legal burden goes back to you as the propounder.
Before the court will require the will to be formally proved, the challenger must point to some evidence that, if accepted, would call its validity into question. That is a minimal threshold. So expect a challenge to reach the proof stage without much difficulty, and prepare accordingly.
What stays on the challenger: undue influence
Undue influence is treated differently. The burden of proving it stays on the people attacking the will, and suspicious circumstances do not shift it to you. Testamentary undue influence means outright and overpowering coercion of the testator, and the challenger must prove it on a balance of probabilities.
The presumption of undue influence that exists for lifetime gifts does not apply to wills, so a challenger gets no presumption and must prove coercion. This is the main place where the defender has a real advantage.
| Issue | Who carries the legal burden |
|---|---|
| Due execution | You, as propounder |
| Knowledge and approval, capacity | You; after suspicious circumstances are raised, the burden returns to you |
| Undue influence | The challenger |
What to do next
Early preparation matters more than argument. A lawyer can tell you how the process runs in your region and what evidence is likely to matter.
- Locate the original will and identify who witnessed it
- Note who helped arrange the will and who was present when it was signed
- Collect medical records or notes from around the time the will was made
- Write down the names of people who dealt with the testator then
- Speak with an estates lawyer about your duties and your exposure
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to prove the will is valid even if I am only the named executor?
If you are the person putting the will forward, the legal burden of proving due execution, knowledge and approval, and capacity rests on you. A presumption helps once due execution is proved.
What counts as suspicious circumstances?
The law refers to evidence of suspicious circumstances without a fixed list in the material here. Once challengers introduce such evidence, the legal burden goes back to you. A lawyer can assess whether the facts in your case would likely qualify.
Who must prove undue influence?
The people attacking the will. The burden stays on them, and suspicious circumstances do not shift it. They must prove outright and overpowering coercion on a balance of probabilities.
Can a challenger rely on a presumption of undue influence against the will?
No. That presumption applies only to lifetime transactions, not to wills.
Sources
- Neuberger v. York, 2016 ONCA 191, para. 78 — ontariocourts.ca
- Seguin v. Pearson, 2018 ONCA 355, para. 11 — ontariocourts.ca
- McGrath v. Joy, 2022 ONCA 119 — ontariocourts.ca
- Succession Law Reform Act, s. 21.1(1) — Ontario e-Laws
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.