- Before a municipality conveys a road allowance that is under water, it must get the consent of the Ministry of Natural Resources under section 43 of the Municipal Act.
- An ordinary sale inside a municipality starts with an application to the municipality, but a submerged strip adds a Ministry step.
- Most lake and river beds are Crown land, and shore lands rules can still apply to work on the water side.
Water levels, erosion and old surveys mean that part of a shore road allowance may now sit under the lake. If you own the cottage lot beside it, you may wonder whether the municipality can still sell you a strip you cannot stand on.
The short answer is that it may be possible, but not as an ordinary municipal sale. This page looks only at what changes when the strip is submerged and how the Crown lake bed and shore lands rules fit in.
How a submerged sale differs from an ordinary one
Inside a municipality, road allowances, including shore road allowances, are under the municipality's jurisdiction unless they have been legally stopped up and sold. To buy one, the owner applies to the municipality.
A submerged allowance adds a step. Before conveying a road allowance that is under water, the municipality must get the consent of the Ministry of Natural Resources under section 43 of the Municipal Act. Council agreeing to sell is therefore not the end of the process.
The price on a municipal sale varies by municipality and by-law, so ask the municipality how it sets the price and what costs you would carry.
Why the lake bed matters
Most lake and river beds in Ontario are Crown land, and shore lands are the lands below the high-water mark or the maximum regulated contour, whichever is higher. Whether a particular strip is in fact submerged, and by how much, is a question of fact that a survey can help answer.
Shore lands are lands below the high-water mark or the maximum regulated contour, whichever is higher. A strip that is partly wet and partly dry may therefore fall partly within shore lands, so the line on the ground matters.
Buying does not remove shore lands rules
A Public Lands Act work permit from the Ministry may be needed to build a structure, such as a dock or boathouse, in physical contact with more than 15 m² of Crown or adjacent shore lands, or to dredge or fill shore lands. Doing such work without a required permit is an offence.
- Structures in contact with 15 m² or less of shore lands are exempt if they meet the conditions in Ontario Regulation 239/13.
- A structure floating over shore lands is not treated as touching them.
- A municipal or conservation authority permit does not replace a Ministry work permit when one is required.
So even if you succeed in buying a submerged strip, you should not assume you can fill it, dredge it or build on it freely.
Other situations to keep apart
In unorganized territory the process is different. Road allowances and Crown-dedicated roads there are under the Minister of Natural Resources and can be stopped up and sold under section 55.1 of the Public Lands Act.
A Crown shoreline reserve is also a separate thing. It is ungranted Crown land no more than 30 metres deep between a water body and private property, and it is under the Minister's jurisdiction in both incorporated and unincorporated areas. Which kind of strip you are dealing with decides who you apply to.
What to do next
- Get a recent survey showing where the water line and the road allowance sit.
- Ask the municipality whether the strip has been stopped up, and whether any part is submerged.
- Ask the municipality whether it would seek Ministry consent and how long that usually takes.
- Confirm whether you are in a municipality or in unorganized territory.
- Check whether any planned dock or shoreline work needs a Ministry work permit.
- Speak with a real estate lawyer before you commit money to a purchase of a submerged strip.
Frequently asked questions
Can a municipality sell a road allowance that is under water?
Possibly, but it must first get the consent of the Ministry of Natural Resources under section 43 of the Municipal Act before conveying it. Whether that consent is given depends on the facts.
Who do I apply to if the strip is partly submerged?
Inside a municipality, the owner applies to the municipality to buy a road allowance, but before conveying a road allowance that is under water, the municipality must get the consent of the Ministry of Natural Resources under section 43 of the Municipal Act. In unorganized territory, road allowances are under the Minister of Natural Resources instead.
Is the lake bed in front of my cottage Crown land?
Most lake and river beds in Ontario are Crown land, and shore lands are the lands below the high-water mark or the maximum regulated contour, whichever is higher.
Does buying the strip let me build a dock over the water?
Not automatically. A Ministry work permit may be needed for a structure in contact with more than 15 m² of Crown or adjacent shore lands, and a municipal permit does not replace it.
Sources
- Ontario – Crown land and shore land work permits — ontario.ca
- Crown Land Management Policies: Public Lands Act work permits — ontario.ca
- Ontario – Road allowances, dedicated roads and Crown shoreline reserves: Disposition policy — ontario.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.