- When no named executor can or will act, a person applies for a grant of administration instead of a grant of probate.
- For administration with will annexed, a beneficiary with the consent of beneficiaries holding a majority in interest ranks first to apply.
- An interested person can push a named executor to act by serving a citation in Form P32, and the executor must respond within 14 days of being served.
You have a will, but the person it names as executor has died, says no, or simply is not doing anything. That can leave beneficiaries unsure whether the estate can move forward at all, and who is allowed to step in.
In British Columbia the answer is usually a different kind of grant. This article covers who ranks first to apply, how to push an executor who is stalling, what renouncing means, and how notice and security differ from a standard probate application.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
When probate turns into administration with will annexed
If the will names no executor, or the named executors cannot or will not act, a person applies for a grant of administration rather than probate.
Common reasons the switch happens:
- The named executor has died.
- The named executor has renounced the appointment.
- The named executor is a former spouse. If you and your spouse stopped being spouses after the will was made, a gift or appointment to that spouse, including as executor, is revoked, and a later reconciliation does not revive it.
- The sole named executor is a minor. In that case the court must grant administration with will annexed to the minor's guardian, or to another suitable person, until the minor reaches 19 years of age.
Who ranks first to apply
When there is a will but no executor can act, the order is: a beneficiary who has the consent of beneficiaries holding a majority in interest, then a nominee, then other beneficiaries, then any person the court appoints.
This differs from the order where there is no will at all, which starts with the spouse or the spouse's nominee and then moves to children. Which order applies depends on whether a valid will exists, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer if the will's status is unclear.
Pushing an executor who will not move, or stepping aside
A person interested in the estate can push a named executor to act by personally serving a citation in Form P32. It requires the executor to apply for probate, and the cited person must respond within 14 days after being served.
An executor who does not want the job can renounce. Unless a court orders otherwise, renouncing ends their executorship. An executor who renounces and has not intermeddled in the estate is not liable. A formal renunciation is usually cleaner than silence, because it lets the next person in line apply.
| Situation | Usual path |
|---|---|
| Executor is willing but slow | Citation in Form P32 |
| Executor renounces | Grant of administration |
| Executor has died | Grant of administration |
Notice and security differences
Before any estate grant application, the applicant must deliver a Notice of Proposed Application in Relation to Estate in Form P1. The application cannot be made until at least 21 days after the notice and materials are delivered.
In an administration application, the P1 notice must tell recipients that they may apply for an order requiring the intended applicant to provide security, unless the applicant is the Public Guardian and Trustee. An applicant for administration does not have to provide security unless a minor or a mentally incapable person without a nominee is interested in the estate, or the court requires it on application by a person interested in the estate.
The notice also goes to the people the rules list, including executors with a prior or equal right, beneficiaries, and certain people who would inherit on an intestacy. Anyone entitled to notice can oppose the grant by filing a notice of dispute in Form P29.
What to do next
- Confirm why the named executor cannot act: death, renunciation, refusal or delay.
- Find the original will and any other wills the person may have made.
- If the executor is only stalling, ask a lawyer whether a citation is the right step.
- Work out who ranks first to apply and whether a majority in interest of beneficiaries will consent.
- Prepare and deliver the Form P1 notice, then wait at least 21 days before filing.
You do not need a lawyer to apply for a grant in British Columbia. Disputes, missing wills or unclear family situations are good reasons to get legal advice first.
Frequently asked questions
What if the named executor never answers?
A person interested in the estate can personally serve a citation in Form P32, which requires the executor to apply for probate. The cited person must respond within 14 days after being served.
Can an executor change their mind after renouncing?
Unless a court orders otherwise, renouncing ends their executorship. Whether a court would allow anything different depends on the facts, so ask a lawyer.
Does the will still matter if someone gets administration with will annexed?
Yes. A grant of administration is used where there is no will, where the will names no executor, or where the named executors cannot or will not act. The administrator then manages the estate under it.
Does the administrator have to post security?
Not usually. Security is required only if a minor or a mentally incapable person without a nominee is interested in the estate, or if the court requires it on application.
Sources
- Province of British Columbia – After a Death: Deal with wills and estates — www2.gov.bc.ca
- Supreme Court Civil Rules, Rule 25-2(1.1) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Wills, Estates and Succession Act, s. 104 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.