- Breaking a mortgage mid-term usually means a prepayment penalty, normally the higher of 3 months' interest on what you still owe or the interest rate differential.
- A longer mortgage term can give a payout right after five years, but not for corporate borrowers.
- A switch only pays off if the interest you save outweighs the penalty and the other costs of moving.
You are partway through your term and rates look better elsewhere. Before you move, the question is what it costs to leave your current lender, because the penalty can swallow much of the saving.
This article is for borrowers mid-term who want to understand how a prepayment penalty is calculated and how to judge whether switching is worth it.
Yes, breaking the contract usually carries a penalty
A closed mortgage is a contract for a set term. If you pay it off early to move to another lender, the lender is entitled to charge what the contract says. Your agreement is the starting point, but if your mortgage term is longer than five years, the Interest Act lets you pay off the principal and interest plus three months' further interest after five years from the mortgage date, unless the borrower is a corporation.
The prepayment penalty is usually the higher of 3 months' interest on what you still owe or the interest rate differential, known as the IRD. Federally regulated lenders must set out prepayment privileges and penalties in an information box at the start of the mortgage agreement.
How the two calculations work
| Method | What it measures | When it applies |
|---|---|---|
| Three months' interest | Three months of interest on what you still owe | When it is the higher of the two amounts |
| Interest rate differential (IRD) | The interest rate differential, as your lender calculates it | When it is the higher of the two amounts |
If you break a mortgage contract, the prepayment penalty is usually the higher of the two amounts. Federally regulated lenders must set out prepayment privileges and penalties in an information box at the start of the mortgage agreement. How the IRD is worked out can differ from one lender to another, so ask for the exact formula and a written payout statement rather than relying on an online calculator.
Rules and exceptions that can change the answer
- Terms longer than five years: after five years from the mortgage date, the borrower may pay off the principal and interest plus three months' further interest in lieu of notice, and no further interest is chargeable.
- Corporate borrowers: that five-year payout right does not apply to a mortgage given by a corporation, or to prescribed mortgages given by prescribed entities.
- Porting: a portable mortgage lets you transfer your balance, rate and terms to a new home, which avoids breaking the contract, but whether and how you can port depends on the lender.
- Porting to a cheaper home: if the new home costs less than the amount of the mortgage, you may still pay a prepayment penalty.
Porting only helps if you are moving homes. If you are staying put and just want a different lender, it will not apply.
When does switching pay off?
Compare what you would save with what you would spend. Savings come from a lower rate over the remaining term. Costs include the penalty, any discharge or administrative fees, and the legal and appraisal costs of the new mortgage. Ask both lenders for their numbers in writing.
- Get a written payout figure from your current lender, showing how the penalty was calculated.
- Ask whether the new lender will cover some costs, and confirm that in writing.
- Compare the interest saved over the time left in your term, not only the new rate.
- Check the new mortgage's own prepayment terms so you do not trade one trap for another.
- Be wary of any lender that tries to rush you; private lenders may charge higher fees.
What to do next
Pull out your mortgage agreement and find the prepayment section and the information box if there is one. Request a payout statement, then ask a licensed broker to price the alternatives. A broker must disclose material risks, its relationship with each lender and any conflict of interest in writing. If the numbers are close or the clauses are unclear, a lawyer can read the contract before you commit.
Frequently asked questions
Is there always a penalty for switching lenders mid-term?
Usually, yes, because you are breaking a contract. The usual penalty is the higher of 3 months' interest on what you still owe or the IRD. Your own agreement sets out the exact terms.
Which is usually bigger, the IRD or three months' interest?
It depends on your rate, the comparison rate and how much of the term remains. The penalty is usually the higher of 3 months' interest on what you still owe or the interest rate differential (IRD).
Can I avoid the penalty by porting?
Possibly, if you are moving homes and your lender allows it, since porting avoids breaking the contract. If the new home costs less than the mortgage amount, you may still pay a penalty.
Does the five-year rule help me?
If your term is longer than five years, you may pay off after five years from the mortgage date with three months' further interest. It does not apply to mortgages given by corporations.
Sources
- Justice Laws – Interest Act, s. 10 — Justice Laws (federal)
- FSRA – Private Mortgages — fsrao.ca
- CanLII – O. Reg. 188/08 (MBLAA) — canlii.org
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada – Choosing a mortgage — canada.ca
- Financial Consumer Agency of Canada – Mortgage fees: Prepayment penalties — canada.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.