- Capacity disputes often turn on evidence about what happened when documents were prepared, which is why the drafting firm's role can become a problem.
- Where a will was duly executed, capacity is presumed, but suspicious circumstances shift the burden to the side defending the will.
- Whether a firm can keep acting is a question for the court and depends on the facts, so get advice early.
You believe a relative did not understand what they were signing. When you raise it, you discover the other side is represented by the same law firm that prepared the will, power of attorney or other documents. That can feel unfair, and it raises a practical question: can that firm really act against you?
This page looks only at that situation. It explains why the drafting firm's lawyers may be involved as sources of evidence, what the dispute itself is about, and what you can do. It does not decide whether any particular firm must step aside. That is a court question that depends on the facts.
This article covers the law of Saskatchewan.
Why the drafting firm's role can become a problem
When a lawyer prepares a will or a power of attorney, that lawyer usually meets the person, takes instructions and watches the document being signed. If someone later says the person lacked capacity, those lawyers may be the people with the most direct knowledge of what happened.
A lawyer who might have to give evidence about those events is in a different position from a lawyer who only argues the case. That is the core concern when a firm is both a source of facts and the advocate for one side. Whether a court will treat it as a reason for the firm to stop acting depends on the facts, and a lawyer can confirm how it applies to you.
What a capacity dispute is actually about
Saskatchewan courts allow a will to be proven in solemn form (Rule 16-48) and allow a caveat to be filed. These are the tools that put a will's validity before the court.
On the burden of proof, where a will is duly executed capacity is presumed, and suspicious circumstances shift the burden to the person putting the will forward. Undue influence and fraud remain the burden of those attacking the will.
Capacity is also assessed in other settings. In the guardianship context it asks whether the person can understand information relevant to a decision and appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of making or not making it. Capacity to grant a power of attorney is both a medical and a legal decision. Testamentary capacity and power of attorney capacity are legal questions decided by a court or lawyer, not by any single assessor.
Questions that help show whether the firm is a witness
- Did a lawyer or staff member from the firm meet the person alone, or was a family member present?
- Who gave the firm its instructions, and who arranged the appointment?
- Did anyone from the firm witness the signing or prepare a witness certificate?
- Did the firm keep notes of what the person said and understood?
- Will the firm's own conduct be questioned in the dispute?
If the honest answer to several of these is yes, the firm's lawyers may be needed to explain what happened. Witnesses to a power of attorney can include a lawyer, who gives legal advice and signs a witness certificate, or two competent adults who meet the requirements. That means a lawyer's certificate or file may itself become evidence.
What the court can be asked to decide
If you think the firm is in a conflicted position, how to raise it depends on your situation, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer before you decide what to do. If that does not resolve it, a lawyer can advise whether to ask the court to decide the issue.
The outcome is not something anyone can promise, and it will turn on what evidence the firm's lawyers would actually be giving.
What to do next
- Write down what you know about how and when the documents were signed.
- Collect any medical notes, assessments or letters that speak to the person's understanding at the time.
- Keep copies of all correspondence with the other side's firm.
- Ask a Saskatchewan lawyer, who is not connected to the drafting firm, whether the firm's role can be challenged and what your options are, including a caveat or proving the will in solemn form.
- Act promptly, because delay can affect your options.
Frequently asked questions
Does the firm that drafted a will always have to step aside if capacity is challenged?
No. Whether a firm must stop acting depends on the facts, including how central its lawyers' evidence is. A lawyer can tell you whether it is worth raising in your situation.
Who has to prove a person lacked capacity in Saskatchewan?
Where a will is duly executed, capacity is presumed. If there are suspicious circumstances, the burden shifts to the person putting the will forward, while undue influence and fraud remain the burden of those attacking the will.
Can I get a medical assessment of capacity after someone has died?
Capacity assessments in the guardianship context are done on a living person by qualified professionals. How capacity is looked at after a death depends on the circumstances, so it is worth confirming with a lawyer what applies to your situation.
What court tools exist to challenge a will in Saskatchewan?
Saskatchewan courts allow a will to be proven in solemn form under Rule 16-48 and a caveat to be filed. A lawyer can explain which fits your situation.
Sources
- Government of Saskatchewan – Powers of attorney for adults — saskatchewan.ca
- Government of Saskatchewan – Is an adult guardian needed? — saskatchewan.ca
- Law Society of Saskatchewan – Case Mail v. 23 no. 19 — lawsociety.sk.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $720.39, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.