- An executor who distributes property without the certificate is personally liable for the unpaid amounts, up to the value of the property distributed.
- A partial distribution can be possible without a certificate for each payment if enough property remains to cover any liability.
- Income paid or allocated to beneficiaries is not a distribution of property, so it does not call for a certificate.
Beneficiaries often expect to be paid soon after probate, and the wait for a CRA clearance certificate can feel like pointless delay. You are the one who signs the cheques, though, and the tax rules put the risk of paying too early on you.
This page looks at the practical question: what you can safely pay while the certificate is pending, and how to think about keeping part of the estate back. It explains how the rules generally work. It cannot set an amount for your estate.
This article covers Canadian federal tax law, which applies in every province.
Why early payments put you at risk
Before distributing property in your possession or control, a legal representative must obtain a certificate from the Minister confirming that the relevant amounts have been paid or secured.
If you distribute without the certificate, you are personally liable for the unpaid amounts, limited to the value of the property distributed, and the Minister may assess you for that amount at any time. The liability applies whether the assessment comes before or after the actual distribution, and interest accrues.
A legal representative is generally the executor named in the will. In Quebec it is the person registered as liquidator, and where there is no will or executor it may be an administrator appointed under provincial or territorial law.
What counts as a distribution
This matters because some payments are safer than others. Distribution happens when you give up control and transfer the property, not when a beneficiary becomes entitled to it.
- Transferring property to a beneficiary is a distribution.
- Appropriating estate property to yourself is also treated as a distribution.
- Trust income paid or allocated to beneficiaries is not a distribution of property, so no certificate is needed for that income.
Estates that had a GST/HST number face a separate requirement: a GST/HST certificate must be obtained before distributing property or money, or the representative is personally liable up to the value distributed.
How much to keep back
You do not need a new certificate before each distribution if enough property remains to cover any liability. This is the basis for a partial distribution with a holdback.
What counts as enough is a judgement about your estate's facts, and a lawyer or accountant can help you make it. It is worth working through the following points:
- Tax on the final return and on the estate's T3 returns, which must be filed and assessed before a certificate issues.
- Interest and penalties, because the certificate covers income taxes, interest, penalties, CPP contributions and EI premiums.
- Possible late-filing penalties, since interest compounds daily on the balance and penalty.
- Any GST/HST account, which needs its own certificate.
- Payroll or other program accounts, which are worth checking directly with CRA because coverage is not confirmed.
When you apply, you must include a statement of distribution to date and the proposed distribution of any holdback or residual. Keeping clear records of what you paid out and what you kept back makes that statement easier.
Setting expectations on timing
CRA does not issue the certificate unless the required returns are filed and assessed and all amounts are paid or secured. The request should not be sent with the tax returns, because that delays their assessment.
After you apply, CRA acknowledges the request within 45 days, and assessment can take up to 120 days if all documents are provided. An audit may be needed first. You can tell beneficiaries that these are targets and can change. If the estate cannot cover all the tax, interest and penalties owing, the certificate is generally not issued.
What to do next
- List every asset and estimate the tax, interest and penalties that could still be owing.
- Confirm that the final return and the estate's T3 returns are filed and assessed.
- Decide with a lawyer or accountant whether a partial distribution is safe, and write down the reasoning.
- Pay trust income to beneficiaries only as the rules allow, and keep the records.
- Tell beneficiaries in writing what is being held back and why.
- Apply with Form TX19 once the returns are assessed and amounts are paid or secured.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a percentage I can safely hold back?
No set percentage applies to every estate. The amount depends on the tax that could still be owing and the property left in the estate, so it is a judgement to confirm with a lawyer or accountant. You must include the proposed holdback in your application.
Can I make a partial distribution before the certificate arrives?
A certificate is not needed before each distribution if enough property remains to cover any liability. If you distribute without one and you are wrong, you are personally liable up to the value distributed.
Can I pay beneficiaries income earned by the estate?
Trust income paid or allocated to beneficiaries is not a distribution of property, so no certificate is needed for it. Capital property is different, so confirm which category a payment falls into first.
What if beneficiaries threaten to sue me for the delay?
Delay is often the safer course when tax is unresolved, since personal liability follows an early distribution. Speak with a lawyer about your duties and about how to explain the delay to beneficiaries.
Sources
- Income Tax Act s. 159 — Justice Laws (federal)
- CRA – IC82-6R13 Clearance Certificate — canada.ca
- CRA – Apply for a clearance certificate — canada.ca
- CRA – Filing and payment due dates — canada.ca
- Excise Tax Act s. 270 — Justice Laws (federal)
- CRA – Represent someone who died — canada.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a tax question
A tax planning consult with us is from $563.87, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.