- A decision-maker at the IRB is assessing whether your account is credible and whether it fits the legal definition of a refugee or person in need of protection.
- Confirming who you are is usually the starting point of any claim: - Passport, national identity card, or birth certificate - Secondary identity evidence if primary documents are…
- - Police reports or complaints, where making one was safe to do - Medical or psychological reports documenting injuries or trauma - Threatening letters, messages, or summonses you…
A refugee claim is decided on the written record and testimony put in front of the Refugee Protection Division (RPD), which means the strength of your evidence for a refugee claim matters as much as how clearly you tell your story. Testimony alone can carry a claim, but corroborating documents make it easier for a decision-maker to accept what you're describing.
This article walks through the broad categories of evidence claimants typically gather, and what to do when a document simply isn't available.
Why Corroborating Evidence Matters
A decision-maker at the IRB is assessing whether your account is credible and whether it fits the legal definition of a refugee or person in need of protection. Documents don't replace your testimony — they support it, filling in details that are hard to convey through words alone and giving the Board something independent to weigh alongside what you say.
Identity Documents
Confirming who you are is usually the starting point of any claim:
- Passport, national identity card, or birth certificate
- Secondary identity evidence if primary documents are unavailable: school records, employment records, religious or community records, family photographs
- A sworn explanation of why a primary document is missing, if that's your situation
Evidence of the Events You Describe
- Police reports or complaints, where making one was safe to do
- Medical or psychological reports documenting injuries or trauma
- Threatening letters, messages, or summonses you received
- Membership cards or records from a political party, religious group, or union relevant to your claim
- Statements from family members, colleagues, or witnesses who can speak to what happened
Country Condition Evidence
- The IRB compiles a National Documentation Package (NDP) for many countries, drawing on government, NGO, and media sources about conditions there
- Independent human rights reports, news coverage, and expert affidavits can supplement the NDP with details specific to your situation or region
- This category matters even when your personal documents are strong, because it shows the general pattern your individual experience fits into
Types of Evidence at a Glance
| Category | Examples | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
| Identity | Passport, ID card, birth certificate | Confirms who you are and your nationality |
| Incident-specific | Police/medical reports, threats, witness letters | Corroborates the specific events you describe |
| Membership/affiliation | Party cards, religious records, employment letters | Supports the basis of the claimed persecution |
| Country conditions | NDP excerpts, NGO/media reports | Shows your account fits a documented pattern |
How Much Evidence Is Enough?
There's no fixed checklist that guarantees a claim succeeds, and more paper isn't automatically better than less. A small number of directly relevant, well-explained documents usually does more for a claim than a large volume of loosely connected material. Focus on evidence that speaks directly to who you are, what happened to you, and why it fits the legal definition of persecution or risk — rather than trying to submit everything you can find.
It also helps to organize your evidence clearly and refer to it specifically in your narrative, so the connection between a document and the point it supports is obvious to whoever is reading the file, rather than left for the decision-maker to work out on their own.
When You Don't Have Documents
Missing documents are common — people flee quickly, leave records behind, or come from places where official documentation is unreliable or dangerous to obtain. A reasonable, honest explanation for a gap is far more useful than silence about it. Address missing evidence directly in your narrative rather than hoping it won't come up.
Getting Documents From Abroad
- Ask trusted family or friends still in the country to retrieve or request records where it's safe to do so
- Local lawyers or agents in your home country can sometimes obtain civil records on your behalf
- Be cautious about contacting your home country's authorities directly, since doing so can create risk depending on your circumstances — discuss this with your lawyer before reaching out
Frequently asked questions
Is my testimony enough if I genuinely have no supporting documents?
Testimony alone can support a claim if it's detailed, consistent, and credible, but the absence of documents means the decision-maker is relying more heavily on your account, so a clear explanation for what's missing matters.
Can social media posts or messages be used as evidence?
Yes, screenshots of messages, posts, or online activity can support a claim, though the Board will consider their authenticity and how they connect to your specific account.
Does everything need to be translated into English or French?
Foreign-language documents generally need a certified translation to be properly considered, so factor translation time into your preparation.
Should I try to get a document from my home country's government if I'm afraid of them?
Not without discussing it with your lawyer first — contacting the very authorities you fear can create safety risks and is not always necessary to support your claim.
Can a friend or family member write a letter to support my claim?
Yes, a detailed, specific letter from someone with direct knowledge of your situation can be useful corroborating evidence, though it will generally carry more weight alongside other supporting documents than as your only piece of evidence.
This is an immigration question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed Ontario lawyer before a dollar is owed.