- A case becomes contested when an answer is filed, and a judge must then hold at least one conference.
- Missed deadlines, service problems and hidden finances are common ways a case heats up.
- Out-of-court processes and a written, witnessed agreement can lower the temperature.
A hostile separation can feel like every message, deadline and document is a fight. "Contentious" is not a legal category, but the court process does have points where conflict tends to grow, and points where it can be contained.
This page looks at what can escalate a case, what case conferences are for, and practical ways to limit conflict while you protect your position. It does not replace advice on your own facts.
What "contentious" means in the court process
In practice, a case becomes contested when the other spouse files an answer. In each case where an answer is filed, a judge must hold at least one conference.
Hostility alone is not the test, but the one-year wait does not apply if the spouse the proceeding is brought against has, since the marriage, committed adultery or treated the other spouse with physical or mental cruelty that makes continued cohabitation intolerable. Breakdown of the marriage can be shown by living separate and apart for at least one year. Adultery or physical or mental cruelty that makes continued cohabitation intolerable is an alternative route with no one-year wait. Arguing about blame is therefore often optional, and it can be costly.
What tends to escalate a case
- Missed or disputed deadlines: a respondent must serve and file an answer within 30 days after being served, or 60 days if served outside Canada and the United States.
- No response: if the respondent does not answer and has not asked for more time, the applicant can take steps toward an uncontested trial decided on the applicant's evidence alone.
- Service fights: an application must be specially served by someone other than the party who has to serve it. If a spouse cannot be served in the usual way, the court may order substituted service.
- Hiding information: a court may set aside a domestic contract if a party failed to disclose significant assets, debts or other liabilities.
- Fault allegations: adultery or cruelty claims invite a response and can also raise questions of condonation.
Many of these are avoidable. Meeting deadlines, using a neutral person for service and giving complete financial disclosure remove common sources of friction.
Case conferences and what to expect
A conference is where a judge or Dispute Resolution Officer meets the parties. Contested cases move through case conferences, settlement conferences, and trial scheduling and trial management conferences, and a trial or focused hearing may be needed if issues remain.
Except in urgent situations, a motion generally cannot be brought until a case conference has been held. This slows down the pressure tactics some people try early on. Financial statements are also part of the process: Form 13 is used for support claims without property claims, and Form 13.1 is used for property claims, with or without support.
Most parties in family cases must also attend a Mandatory Information Program no later than 45 days after the case is started. Before granting a divorce, the court must also be satisfied that reasonable arrangements have been made for the support of any children of the marriage.
Ways to limit conflict
Parties to a Divorce Act proceeding must try to resolve matters through a family dispute resolution process where appropriate. That means a process outside court, including negotiation, mediation and collaborative law. A lawyer acting for a spouse must discuss the possibility of reconciliation and encourage the client to try such a process unless the circumstances clearly make that inappropriate.
- Mediation or negotiation can keep decisions in your hands rather than a judge's.
- In collaborative family law, the lawyers' retainer includes a disqualification agreement under which both lawyers must withdraw if the matter goes to court, and the participation agreement commits the parties to full, voluntary disclosure.
- A separation agreement can cover property, support and parenting, but it is unenforceable unless it is in writing, signed and witnessed.
- A family arbitration award is enforceable only if, among other conditions, each party received independent legal advice before making the arbitration agreement.
These routes are not right for every case, particularly where safety is a concern. A lawyer can help you decide.
What to do next
- Calendar every deadline and keep proof of when documents were served.
- Keep communication short, written and focused on the issues.
- Gather full financial records before disclosure is requested.
- Ask a lawyer whether mediation or collaborative law suits your situation.
- Raise any safety concerns with your lawyer right away.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to prove my spouse was at fault to get a divorce?
No. Breakdown of the marriage can be shown by living separate and apart for at least one year. Adultery or cruelty is an alternative route, not a requirement.
What happens if my spouse does not answer the divorce papers?
A respondent must serve and file an answer within 30 days after being served with the application, or within 60 days if they were served outside Canada and the United States. If they do not answer and have not asked for more time, the applicant can take steps toward an uncontested trial decided on the applicant's evidence alone.
Is a case conference the same as a trial?
No. A conference is where a judge or Dispute Resolution Officer meets the parties. A trial or focused hearing may be needed only if issues are still unresolved afterwards.
Do we have to try mediation before going to court?
Parties to a Divorce Act proceeding must try to resolve matters through a family dispute resolution process where appropriate. Lawyers must encourage this unless the circumstances clearly make it inappropriate.
Sources
- Divorce Act, s. 8(2)(a) — Justice Laws (federal)
- Divorce Act, s. 11(1) — Justice Laws (federal)
- Divorce Act, s. 2(1) definition of 'family dispute resolution process' — Justice Laws (federal)
- Divorce Act, s. 7.7 — Justice Laws (federal)
- Department of Justice Canada – The Emerging Phenomenon of Collaborative Family Law (research report) — justice.gc.ca
- Family Law Rules, r. 6(3), 6(4.1) — Ontario e-Laws
- Superior Court of Justice – The Steps in a Family Case — ontariocourts.ca
- Family Law Act, ss. 54, 55(1) — Ontario e-Laws
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a family law question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.