- When presenting an offer to a seller, a licensee must disclose the seller's payments to the listing brokerage, payments to any cooperating brokerage, amounts retained and other licensee remuneration.
- A licensee must not request or agree to remuneration based on the difference between the listed price and the actual sale price.
- A complaint to the superintendent must be in writing and include particulars.
Sellers sometimes look back at a sale and wonder whether they were told everything about who got paid and how much. Maybe a figure in the closing documents surprised you, or you suspect the other side's brokerage received a share you never saw explained.
This article focuses on the remuneration disclosure rules that apply to your realtor and shows how to frame a suspected breach as a written complaint to BCFSA.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
The disclosure rules your realtor had to follow
When presenting an offer to a seller, the licensee must disclose the seller's payments to the listing brokerage, payments to any cooperating brokerage, amounts retained and other licensee remuneration.
Separately, a licensee must promptly disclose to the client all remuneration paid or payable to the licensee's related brokerage, including its source and amount.
There is also a firm prohibition. A licensee must not request or agree to remuneration based on the difference between the listed price and the actual sale price, and cannot keep remuneration calculated that way.
Matching your concern to a rule
| What you suspect | Rule that may be relevant |
|---|---|
| Nobody explained what the listing brokerage and any cooperating brokerage would be paid when the offer was presented | Disclosure of payments to the listing brokerage, cooperating brokerage, amounts retained and other licensee remuneration |
| Remuneration going to the realtor's related brokerage was not explained, including its source and amount | Prompt disclosure of all remuneration paid or payable to the related brokerage |
| The realtor's pay depended on the gap between the listed and actual sale price | No remuneration based on that difference |
| The agent was paid directly by someone other than their own brokerage | Agents cannot accept remuneration for real estate services from anyone but their own brokerage |
Whether a rule was actually breached depends on the facts and your documents. The superintendent makes that judgment, not you.
Framing it as a complaint
Any person may complain to the superintendent if they believe a licensee may have committed professional misconduct or conduct unbecoming. The complaint must be in writing and include particulars. Professional misconduct includes contravening the Act, wrongful taking or deceptive dealing, and incompetence.
Frame your complaint around what was or was not disclosed, and when. For example, say that you were presented an offer and no breakdown of remuneration was provided, then attach what you did receive. Avoid guessing at motives.
What to gather and include
- Your service agreement, including the clause on remuneration and the circumstances in which it is payable.
- The offer you received and any cover emails or notes that came with it.
- Closing statements showing what was paid and to whom.
- Any messages in which you asked about commission and the answers you were given.
- A short, dated timeline of the sale from listing to completion.
- The name of the realtor and brokerage, and what you believe was left out.
What happens next and practical steps
The superintendent may investigate, inspect and copy records at business premises, and require answers or production. Brokerage records must generally be kept at least 7 years after creation unless the superintendent authorizes a shorter period. Unless your complaint is anonymous, the superintendent must acknowledge it and inform you of the outcome.
Discipline orders can include a reprimand, suspension or cancellation, conditions, required training and a discipline penalty up to $500 000 for a brokerage. However, the discipline process provides no damages to you. Compensation is available only through the Special Compensation Fund for compensable loss, and claims for remuneration are excluded.
If you think you lost money because of undisclosed payments, speak with a lawyer about your options in addition to any complaint. Check BCFSA's current guidance before you submit.
Frequently asked questions
What must a realtor disclose about commission when presenting an offer?
The licensee must disclose the seller's payments to the listing brokerage, payments to any cooperating brokerage, amounts retained and other licensee remuneration. They must also promptly disclose to the client all remuneration paid or payable to the licensee's related brokerage, including its source and amount.
Can a realtor keep the difference between the listed price and the sale price?
No. A licensee must not request or agree to remuneration based on that difference, and cannot keep remuneration calculated that way.
Will a complaint get my money back?
Not through the discipline process, which provides no damages for the complainant. Compensation is limited to the Special Compensation Fund for compensable loss, which excludes claims for remuneration.
Does my complaint have to be in writing?
Yes. A complaint to the superintendent must be in writing and include particulars.
Sources
- Real Estate Services Rules, ss. 43–44 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Real Estate Services Act, s. 7(3)(b) — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
A home purchase with us is from $1,900.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.