- A missing permit can be the kind of defect a seller must disclose, because RECA's bulletin gives a seller lacking the appropriate permits as an example.
- Sellers must disclose material latent defects they know about, and a realtor acting as your sole agent must also disclose to buyers any such defect they know of, so staying silent does not make the problem go away.
- Caveat emptor has exceptions for fraud, misrepresentation and express warranties, and a buyer generally has 2 years from when they knew or ought to have known to sue.
You may know that a basement, deck or renovation in your home was finished without the proper permits. It is natural to wonder whether "buyer beware" means the buyer has to find that out for themselves.
This page looks at one question: does a missing permit count as a material latent defect that you need to disclose? It explains the rules in general terms. Your own facts matter, so a lawyer can confirm how they apply to you.
This article covers the law of Alberta.
Does a missing permit count as a material latent defect?
The Real Estate Act Rules define a material latent defect as one that cannot be discerned through a reasonable inspection of the property. It also covers a defect that makes the property dangerous or potentially dangerous to occupants, or unfit for habitation.
A buyer can walk through a finished basement and see nothing wrong. Missing paperwork is not something an inspection will show. RECA's information bulletin says a defect can be more than physical, and gives the example of a seller who lacks the appropriate building or other permits for the property.
Whether your particular situation meets the definition depends on the facts, such as what work was done and what it affects. That is worth confirming with a lawyer.
What buyer beware does and does not protect
Caveat emptor is the common-law starting point. Without an express warranty, a contractual condition, a collateral contract, fraud, or error in substantialibus, the buyer takes the land with its defects after conveyance and cannot reopen the contract.
It does not protect a seller who commits fraud or misrepresentation, gives an express warranty, or makes a collateral contract. The doctrine has also been eroding, and its exceptions are growing.
RECA says sellers cannot hide defects or mislead buyers about a property's condition, and must disclose material latent defects they know about.
Who has to disclose, and what your realtor will do
A seller's licensee acting as sole agent must disclose to all buyers all material latent defects affecting the property that the licensee knows of.
A seller's licensee must also disclose to the seller, in a timely manner, all relevant facts affecting the transaction that the licensee knows of. Under transaction brokerage, the brokerage must disclose to the buyer all material latent defects it knows of.
The duty is not unlimited. RECA states that a seller has no obligation to tell potential buyers that the home is conditionally sold when accepting offers, because disclosure duties attach to material latent defects and similar facts, not to every fact a seller knows.
What can happen if a defect is not disclosed
- A buyer must generally seek a remedial order within 2 years of when they knew or ought to have known of the injury, that it was caused by the seller's conduct, and that a proceeding is warranted. Claims are also barred 10 years after the claim arose, and whichever period ends first applies. These limitation periods are suspended while the buyer is a person under disability.
- The 10-year period is suspended while a defendant fraudulently conceals the injury, so a seller who concealed a defect cannot rely on it while the concealment continues.
- A purchase contract cannot shorten the buyer's time to sue, because an agreement that reduces a limitation period is invalid.
- A buyer who keeps acting as owner for a long time after learning of the problem may be treated as having confirmed the sale, which can bar rescission even when fraud is alleged.
Courts have also said an innocent misrepresentation is not enough to undo a completed land sale, and nothing short of fraud will suffice for rescission. That does not make silence safe. Each situation turns on its facts.
What to do next
- Gather what you have: permit records, contractor invoices, plans and any correspondence with the municipality.
- Tell your realtor what you know about the work, so they can meet their own disclosure duties.
- Do not make statements to buyers about permits or the work that you cannot support.
- Ask a lawyer how the missing permits should be handled before you list, and how any wording in the purchase contract applies.
- Keep your records of what was disclosed and when.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to disclose a deck built without a permit in Alberta?
RECA's bulletin gives a seller lacking the appropriate building or other permits as an example of a defect that is more than physical. Sellers must disclose material latent defects they know about. Whether your deck meets the definition depends on the facts, so ask a lawyer.
Does caveat emptor protect me if the buyer never asked about permits?
Not reliably. Caveat emptor does not protect a seller who commits fraud or misrepresentation. RECA also says sellers cannot hide defects or mislead buyers about condition.
Can I just tell my realtor and let them handle it?
If your realtor is acting as your sole agent, they must disclose to all buyers any material latent defects affecting the property that they know of, so telling them about a known defect means it must reach buyers, and it does not remove your own duty as a seller to disclose material latent defects you know about. Telling them is the safe step, but expect the information to reach buyers.
How long can a buyer wait before suing over a hidden problem?
A buyer generally has 2 years from when they knew or ought to have known of the injury, subject to a 10-year outer limit. That limit is suspended while a defendant fraudulently conceals the injury.
Sources
- Real Estate Council of Alberta – Real Estate Act Rules, s. 1(1)(t) — reca.ca
- RECA information bulletin – Material Latent Defects — reca.ca
- RECA – Ask Charles: conditional sales — reca.ca
- Limitations Act, RSA 2000, c L-12, s. 3(1) — kings-printer.alberta.ca
- CanLII – Caveat Emptor and the Sale of Land: The Erosion of a Doctrine (2001) — canlii.org
- CanLII – Shortt v. MacLennan, 1958 CanLII 11 (SCC), [1959] SCR 3 — canlii.org
- CanLII – 1978 CanLII 169 (SCC) — canlii.org
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a real estate question
A home sale with us is from $1,137.95, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.