- The society must decide whether you can provide a safe home environment, and that decision rests on interviews, a home assessment and record checks.
- Even if the society says no, the court must consider placing the child with a relative or member of the community before ordering removal or society care.
- Ask for the reasons, address any concerns that can be fixed, and get legal advice about raising the issue in court.
You may have stepped forward to care for a niece, nephew, grandchild or another child, and the society has said no. That can be upsetting, especially when you believe the child belongs with family.
The society's decision is important, but it is not the last word in every case. This page explains what the society is required to look at, how to respond to a refusal, and how the court can come into it. Your options depend on the facts and the stage of the case, so confirm them with a lawyer.
What the society must look at
Before placing a child with kin, the society must decide whether the person is capable of providing the child with a safe home environment. It must identify every person 18 or older living in the home and how they are related to the child, interview you, meet privately with the child, assess the home including its physical features, and review society records for every adult in the home.
It must also tell you about the police record check and offence declaration requirements and get your consent to disclosure, then search the Child Protection Fast Track Information System and ask other jurisdictions for their records within seven days of consent. A concern about anyone in your household, not only you, can affect the outcome.
Common reasons for a refusal
The society's reasons will be specific to your case, and it is worth asking for them. They generally relate to the factors above.
- Concerns about the home itself, such as space or safety features
- Information about another adult living in the home
- Results from record checks or society records
- A view that the placement would not meet the child's needs
- Who counts as a relative or community member, which may need to be shown
If the child already lives with you when the society learns of it, it must decide within seven days whether you are providing a safe home environment and then run the same checks on every adult in the home.
Asking the society to reconsider
There is no single step-by-step reconsideration process to point to here, so ask the worker or supervisor how the society handles it. In any case, you can improve your position by responding to the stated concerns.
- Ask for the reasons in writing, or write down what you were told and when.
- Fix what can be fixed, such as home safety issues or sleeping arrangements.
- Give the society anything that answers its concerns, such as references or documents.
- If another adult in the home is the problem, think about whether living arrangements can change, and get advice first.
- If you live outside the society's area, the assessment may be referred to another Ontario society or help may be requested from an out-of-province authority.
If the child is First Nations, Inuk or Métis, the society must consult the child's bands and communities, and customary care may also be relevant.
Taking the issue to court
The court has its own duties on this subject. Before placing a child in society care on a temporary basis, it must consider whether it is in the child's best interests to place the child with a relative or a member of the child's extended family or community. Before ordering removal at the final stage, it must consider placing the child, with consent, with a relative, neighbour or other member of the child's community under a supervision order.
A court may also grant custody to a person, such as a grandparent, if that better serves the child's best interests and the person consents. If you have cared for the child continuously during the six months before the hearing, you get the same notice as a party and may attend, have a lawyer and make submissions. Taking any further part needs the court's leave.
The court looks at best interests, including relationships with family and community and the risk of harm from removal. How you fit into a given case, and what to file, is something a lawyer should advise on.
What to do next
- Gather your documents: proof of your relationship, your contact details and details about your household.
- Ask for the society's reasons and keep every message.
- Speak with a family lawyer soon, since hearings move on a tight timetable.
- Be ready to tell the court how you would meet the child's needs day to day.
Frequently asked questions
Does a no from CAS end my chance to care for the child?
Not necessarily. The court must consider placing a child with a relative or community member before ordering society care or removal. A lawyer can tell you how to put your plan before the court.
Can I get custody instead of a placement?
The court may grant custody to a person, such as a grandparent, if that better serves the child's best interests and the person consents. A custody order cannot be made in favour of a foster parent under that section.
Does the society have to check everyone in my home?
Yes. It must identify every person 18 or older in the home and review society records for each of them. Record checks and consent are part of the process.
What if the child is Indigenous?
The society must consult the child's bands and communities, and the court has to place the child with extended family if possible, unless there is a substantial reason to place the child elsewhere.
Sources
- Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, S.O. 2017, c. 14, Sched. 1 (e-Laws) — Ontario e-Laws
- O. Reg. 156/18 (General) (e-Laws) — Ontario e-Laws
- Family Law Rules, O. Reg. 114/99 (e-Laws) — Ontario e-Laws
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a family law question
Start a file online — flat, published fees, reviewed by a licensed lawyer before a dollar is owed.