- Reasonable fees for administering the estate are an estate expense, and beneficiaries can challenge them when accounts are passed.
- A person interested in the estate may apply to pass accounts or fix the personal representative's remuneration under Rule 25-13(1).
- An executor can be ordered to repay fees that were unreasonable or that were for the executor's own personal dispute rather than the estate's administration.
If you are a beneficiary and the executor's compensation or the lawyer's bill looks too high, you are not without options. The court has a process to look at what has been charged to the estate.
This page explains how a review works, what the executor is allowed to claim, and what you can do before going to court.
This article covers the law of British Columbia.
What can be charged to the estate
Legal fees may be paid from the estate, and there is no rule that they be approved before payment. Reasonable fees for administering the estate are an estate expense.
The executor may also claim a fair and reasonable allowance for care, pains, trouble and time spent, not exceeding 5% of the gross aggregate value of the estate's assets. That allowance is allowed by the Supreme Court or by a registrar if directed by the court. It does not apply where the instrument creating the trust, such as a will, sets the compensation.
Remuneration is allowed when the accounts are passed, in addition to other allowances for expenses actually incurred.
Where the line is crossed
An executor can be ordered to repay fees that were unreasonable, or that were for the executor's own personal dispute rather than the estate's administration. Whether a given bill falls on the wrong side of that line depends on the facts, including what the work was for.
If the executor needs the court's help with a genuine question about administering the estate, the executor may petition for advice or direction, and costs of that application are in the court's discretion.
Asking for a passing of accounts
Under Rule 25-13(1) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules, a personal representative or a person interested in the estate may apply to pass accounts or to fix the personal representative's remuneration. A beneficiary is a person interested in the estate. The court may decide any matter relating to the accounts or remuneration.
An affidavit in Form P38 or a statement of account in Form P40 is filed. The court can also settle the amount of compensation on application.
Costs on these applications are assessed as special costs unless the court orders otherwise. That means there is a cost risk to think through before you apply.
Steps before you apply
- Ask the executor in writing for an accounting of money received, paid and held, and for copies of legal invoices.
- Ask whether the will sets the executor's compensation, since that can change what applies.
- Note which charges concern you and why, such as unclear work, duplicated work or work that looks personal to the executor.
- Ask if the executor will explain or adjust the charges voluntarily.
A calm, documented request often clarifies things. If it does not, the court process above is available.
What to do next
- Gather the will, any correspondence and every account or invoice you have received.
- Write down your specific concerns, item by item.
- Send a written request for accounts and invoices to the executor.
- Speak with a lawyer about whether to apply under Rule 25-13 and what the cost risk is.
- Do not wait without acting if you suspect money is being spent improperly, since the right step may depend on timing.
Frequently asked questions
Does the executor need approval before paying the estate's lawyer?
There is no rule that legal fees be approved before payment. Beneficiaries can challenge them later when accounts are passed.
Who can apply to pass the accounts?
A personal representative or a person interested in the estate may apply to pass accounts or fix the personal representative's remuneration. A beneficiary generally qualifies as a person interested.
Is there a cap on what an executor can be paid?
The allowance for care, pains, trouble and time spent cannot exceed 5% of the gross aggregate value of the estate's assets. It does not apply where the will or other instrument sets the compensation.
Who pays the costs of a passing of accounts?
Costs on these applications are assessed as special costs unless the court orders otherwise. Ask a lawyer how that could affect you before you apply.
Sources
- Province of British Columbia, After a Death: Deal with wills and estates — www2.gov.bc.ca
- Trustee Act, s. 88 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
- Supreme Court Civil Rules, Rule 25-13 — bclaws.gov.bc.ca
Links go to official government, court and regulator pages. The law changes — confirm you are reading the current version.
This is a wills & estates question
A single will with us is from $894.88, tax included. Third-party fees are extra.